Wayfair CEO Calls Share Gains 'Structural' As Orders Climb 12% — And Puts Profit Dollars Ahead Of Margin

Niraj Shah says the home category is flat and Wayfair's growth is its own doing, with a fourth-quarter adjusted EBITDA margin guided to 6% to 7%.

Share
Wayfair CEO Calls Share Gains 'Structural' As Orders Climb 12% — And Puts Profit Dollars Ahead Of Margin

Wayfair's gains are "structural," co-founder and CEO Niraj Shah said on the company's third-quarter earnings call Wednesday, as U.S. revenue grew double digits against what he called a "roughly flat category." Wayfair, the online seller of furniture, décor and housewares, also said it will chase profit dollars ahead of margin rate.

Orders, not basket size, drove the quarter

Shah said the double-digit U.S. growth puts Wayfair's share spread, the gap between its growth and the category's, in double digits, as the company had promised for 2026. Growth came from orders, which rose 12% year over year, he said. Active customers rose more than 4%, and new customer orders rose over 14%, which he called another post-pandemic record.

He argued order growth compounds over time while average order value does not. Asked whether the company is outperforming because of structural strengths or the environment, Shah said the drivers "would matter whether it was an up market or a down market from a macro standpoint."

CFO Kate Gulliver said total revenue grew 9.7%, with the U.S. segment up 11.4% and international down 2.3%. Adjusted EBITDA was $236 million, a 6.9% margin, and net income was $62 million, more than $160 million better than a year earlier. Free cash flow was $136 million.

Profit dollars over margin rate

Pressed by a Morgan Stanley analyst on whether margin is being de-emphasized, Shah said the company is optimizing for EBITDA dollar growth. Margin rate will keep rising, he said, but over-optimizing it "may end up with less dollars than you could otherwise."

Gulliver said contribution margin was 16.1% in the quarter, and that roughly 15% remains the right operating level. Advertising was 9.9% of net revenue, the first single-digit reading since 2021, though she said part of the outperformance was timing.

Fourth-quarter guide and the October question

A JPMorgan analyst asked whether October showed softness or spending deferred past the election. Shah said the category "continues to bump along," probably near the low end of its cycle, and the company's momentum is "not necessarily because the macro is changing at all."

Gulliver guided fourth-quarter revenue growth to the high single digits, below the third quarter's pace, with adjusted EBITDA margin of 6% to 7%. Advertising should rise to 10.5% to 11.5% of net revenue ahead of the holidays. She said Wayfair's Way Day sales event last week set the quarter up well.

Wayfair, which also runs physical stores, plans five new store openings next year. Gulliver said Atlanta and Columbus are showing results similar to Chicago's.

Gulliver's guide for the fourth quarter puts advertising at 10.5% to 11.5% of net revenue, up from 9.9% in the third.

Sources

More on Wayfair

All Wayfair (W) coverage →