Vale Says 160 Million Tons Of Iron Ore Supply Is Losing Money, Flags About 5 Million Of Its Own At Risk

Vale's CEO said about 10% of seaborne iron ore supply should shut or adjust, and detail on its own exposure is due in December.

Share
Vale Says 160 Million Tons Of Iron Ore Supply Is Losing Money, Flags About 5 Million Of Its Own At Risk

Vale CEO Gustavo Pimenta said on the miner's third-quarter earnings call Friday that about 10% of seaborne iron ore supply, or 160 million tons, is losing money and "should be over time shut down or adjusted." Applied to Vale itself, he said, roughly 5 million tons of its own and third-party volume is at risk next year.

Five million tons, and a skeptical analyst

Pimenta said some of the loss-making capacity has already left the market. For Vale, he said, "about 5 million tons between third party and on production" could eventually be adjusted down next year, with detail promised at Valley Day, the company's investor event in December.

An HSBC analyst said he was surprised the number was so small. He put Vale's third-party ore purchases at about 30 million tons a year and noted that skipping them would also spare the company from buying spot freight.

Rogério Nogueira, Vale's executive vice president for commercial and development, said every third-party volume carries a positive contribution margin. Contracts are short-term or priced flexibly, he said, and "if any of those volumes come into negative territory, we would stop it." He credited Vale's own ports, special railway rates and long-term vessel charters for its margin advantage.

Marginal producers first, majors maybe

Asked what happens if Chinese demand weakens further, Pimenta said most of the capacity that exits should come from marginal producers, which cannot lock in freight the way Vale can. He added that he could "see some of the majors also adjusting their capacity going forward."

The question lands as iron ore prices have fallen on expectations of weaker Chinese demand, according to a Reuters report. The same report said Vale's third-quarter iron ore output of 88.4 million tons missed the Visible Alpha consensus of 90.1 million tons, and that the company expects the lower end of its 335 million to 345 million ton guidance.

Freight cover and quarterly numbers

Pimenta said iron ore production fell 6% from a year earlier, mainly on weakness at Serra Norte, while sales held at 86.3 million tons. Executive Vice President of Operations Carlos Medeiros said October daily output there is already 15% above September.

Pimenta said Vale's long-term shipping contracts delivered a benefit of more than $3 billion against the spot market in 2026. Spot rates on the Brazil-China route rose $12 per ton since the first quarter, while Vale's realized freight cost rose $4.7 per ton.

Finance chief Marcelo Bacci said pro forma EBITDA was $3.5 billion, 20% lower than a year earlier, with a 10% drop in realized iron ore prices. Free cash flow was $2.2 billion, and expanded net debt ended at $16.4 billion. Shares rose after the results, Seeking Alpha reported.

Management said it will detail the iron ore volumes at risk, 2027 cost guidance and its productivity program at Valley Day in December.

Sources

More on Vale

All Vale (VALE) coverage →