Vail Resorts Board Challenger Targets Director's Seat As Pass Sales And Resort Earnings Fall
Gregory S. Meyer backs Epic Pass but wants automated dining, faster rental pickup and a plan for debt due in 2030.
Vail Resorts, which operates ski resorts and surrounding lodging and real estate, faces a push to replace director Peter A. Vaughn over falling pass sales and weaker resort earnings. Independent board candidate Gregory S. Meyer urged shareholders Thursday to elect him and withhold votes from Vaughn in an SEC-filed presentation challenging his oversight of branding, customer loyalty and growth.
Fewer Passes, Lower Returns
Meyer cited a 12% year-over-year decline in pass units for the 2026/27 season through September 18, with sales dollars down 6%. He argued that higher prices were no longer making up for lost customers. Pass units have declined for three consecutive seasons and were 15% below their 2023/24 peak, according to his presentation.
His financial case centers on approximately $1.4 billion spent on capital projects and acquisitions from fiscal 2022 through fiscal 2026. Over that period, reported resort earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization fell 11%, to $746 million from $837 million. The corresponding margin declined to 26.3% from 33.1%.
Meyer's presentation put Vail's five-year total return, including reinvested dividends, at minus 50.1% through June 17, 2026, against a 49.3% gain for the Russell Midcap. Vail ranked 14th among 15 proxy peers over that period and last over three years.
Meyer identified $1.74 billion of debt coming due in fiscal 2030—approximately 55% of Vail's debt. He said net debt had climbed to 3.9 times EBITDA from 2.0 times, and to 11.8 times free cash flow from 3.1 times.
Keep Epic, Change The Experience
Meyer wants to retain Vail's resort ownership model and Epic Pass strategy. “We seek one seat, not control,” he wrote.
Vail's Mountain business operates 42 destination resorts and regional ski areas, earning money from passes, lift tickets, ski school, dining, retail and rentals. Mountain and Lodging accounted for about 88% and 12% of fiscal 2026 net revenue, respectively. Its North American resorts recorded approximately 13.1 million skier visits in the 2025/2026 season.
Meyer's proposed changes include cashierless food purchases, more dining sales points and automated lockers for rental gear. He argues those systems could shorten queues and reduce rental labor costs. He also wants skiers to order food from chairlifts through the app and wants each mountain's marketing to retain its distinct identity.
Guest experience forms another part of his challenge. Meyer cited SKI Magazine rankings in which Whistler was Vail's only resort among the Eastern and Western top 10 lists; Vail Mountain fell to 24th from 12th. He also pointed to the Park City patrol strike from December 27, 2024, to January 8, 2025, citing closed terrain, long lines and negative publicity.
Competing Candidates, Separate Campaigns
Meyer, president of Tribeca Capital Management and a former Blockbuster director, has worked in bond trading and automated rental businesses. He reported owning 3,052 Vail shares, all purchased in the open market with his own money, and said he had no financial agreements with Oasis Management.
Oasis, the investment manager conducting a separate board campaign, nominated Robert Chapek and M. Ashton Hudson on November 2. It said its managed funds held approximately 10% of Vail's shares and blamed falling visits, weaker margins and repeated guidance cuts for poor shareholder returns.
Meyer's presentation said Vail's board declined to recommend dissident nominees on October 13. He proposed a settlement Friday and filed his definitive proxy Tuesday.
Vail's annual shareholder meeting is scheduled for December 14, when investors will vote on the board candidates.
Sources
- DFAN14A — Meyer Gregory S re: VAIL RESORTS INC (MTN) — SEC EDGAR
- Oasis Management Sends Letter to Vail Resorts Shareholders in Connection with the Company's 2026 Annual Meeting – Company Announcement - FT.com — Financial Times