RLI Posts An 86.2 Combined Ratio While E&S Property Premium Falls 17% And E&S Casualty 10%
The insurer's call transcript shows a higher combined ratio than a year ago, umbrella and marine growth, and double-digit E&S premium declines.
RLI's third-quarter combined ratio was 86.2, versus 85.1 a year earlier, CFO Aaron Diefenthaler said on the company's Tuesday earnings call. The transcript, furnished in an 8-K filed Wednesday, shows executives holding the line on pricing while E&S property and E&S casualty premium both shrank by double digits.
The quarter in numbers
A combined ratio below 100 means underwriting profit. RLI's underwriting income was $58.8 million. The loss ratio rose 1.3 points to 47.4, and the expense ratio improved modestly to 38.8, Diefenthaler said.
Operating earnings were $0.86 per share, against $0.82 a year ago. Net earnings were $0.88 per share, down from $1.35, which Diefenthaler said came mainly from changes in the value of equity securities between periods. Gross premiums written grew 2% and net investment income rose 13% to $46.7 million.
Favorable development on prior-year reserves was $22.9 million, up from $15.5 million in the third quarter of 2025. Current-year catastrophe losses were about $4 million, mostly in Property. The company also recorded a comprehensive loss of $36.8 million, or 40 cents per share, versus comprehensive earnings of $152 million a year ago, as rising yields cut bond prices.
RLI paid its regular $0.18 dividend and bought back just under 104,000 shares at an average $60.51. About $232 million remained under the buyback authorization at September 30.
Where premium grew and where it shrank
COO Jennifer Klobnak said E&S Property premium fell 17% as new capacity entered and standard carriers reclaimed business. E&S Casualty fell 10%, with pressure from new entrants, and Transportation fell 9% even as rates rose 12%.
Personal Umbrella premium grew 22% on 8% rate increases, and Marine grew 11%. Hawaii Homeowners rose 9%. Steadily, the landlord-insurance partner, produced $9 million of premium and helped offset some of the property decline.
On property, Klobnak said: "We continue to prioritize underwriting discipline over premium retention." She added that RLI is comfortable letting business leave when pricing misses its return targets. Asked how much further E&S Property could fall, she said, "we still have a ways to go."
What to watch
Klobnak said the next approved Personal Umbrella rate filing takes effect January 1, and she expects rate increases to return to double digits during 2027. She also expects a positive result from reinsurance renewals at January 1.
She said Umbrella rates are up about 50% over three years, but RLI is holding its loss-ratio picks until it has more evidence.
For the first nine months, RLI reported $176 million of underwriting income on an 85.9 combined ratio, with operating earnings of $2.52 per share.
Sources
- 8-K Filing — RLI CORP (RLI) — SEC EDGAR
- Exhibit rli-ex99d1.htm — RLI CORP 8-K exhibit — SEC EDGAR