RLI Lets Property And Trucking Premium Slip As Rivals Cut Rates, Still Posts An 86 Combined Ratio
E&S property premium fell 17% and transportation fell 9%, while RLI's total premium grew 2%, executives said on the call.
RLI's Chief Operating Officer, Jen Klobnak, said on the specialty insurer's third-quarter earnings call that in some sectors competitors are "hungry for growth and aggressively cutting rates and expanding terms and conditions." Even so, the company grew premium 2% and posted an 86 combined ratio, a measure of underwriting profit where lower is better.
Where premium is falling
Klobnak said premium in excess and surplus (E&S) property fell 17% as new capacity entered and standard carriers and retailers reclaimed business that had gone through wholesalers. Renewal pricing dropped by double digits on accounts in their second renewal of this softening cycle. Retention is slightly below historical levels, and she said RLI is "comfortable allowing business to move when pricing does not meet our return targets."
Transportation premium fell 9% even as rates rose 12%. Klobnak said RLI non-renewed select accounts that missed profit expectations or ignored loss-control recommendations, and that competition from established markets and re-emerging managing general agents (MGAs) pushed renewal retention down almost 10 points.
E&S casualty premium fell 10%, with new entrants pressuring retention and new business, particularly in the Northeast. Surety premium rose 1%, though she said some competitors are asking almost no questions and not requiring indemnity.
Asked how much further E&S property could fall, Klobnak said "the market will continue to soften" and "we still have a ways to go." She called it a softening market rather than a soft one.
Discipline over budgets
Klobnak said RLI does not enforce top-line budgets on underwriters, who are "empowered to pull back when market conditions do not support our profitability objectives." On large transportation accounts, she said rivals chasing premium is "a little bit nonsensical given the severity."
Chief Executive Craig Kliethermes opened the call by pointing to the 86 combined ratio, 2% premium growth, a 13% rise in net investment income and 10% book value growth from year-end, including dividends and buybacks. "At RLI, we think boring is beautiful," he said, and he closed with "Being different still works."
Chief Financial Officer Aaron Diefenthaler said operating earnings were 86 cents per share, against 82 cents a year earlier. The combined ratio was 86.2 against 85.1, and underwriting income was $58.8 million. Net earnings were 88 cents per share against $1.35, which he tied mainly to changes in equity-security values.
Where growth is coming from
Marine premium grew 11%, personal umbrella 22% on 8% rate increases, and Hawaii homeowners 9% on 13% rate. Klobnak said a partnership with Steadily, a landlord-insurance specialist, produced $9 million of premium. She said RLI turns down over 99% of MGAs that want its paper, and that commissions on the Steadily book run a couple of points higher.
She said the next approved umbrella rate filing takes effect January 1, and she expects rate increases to return to double digits during 2027. On reinsurance, she expects "a positive result" for the January 1 renewal.
Kliethermes told listeners the company will keep saying "no thank you" when an opportunity is not right, and he said RLI likes its position.