Murphy USA CEO On QuickChek: 'To Be Quite Candid,' Pressure Will Persist

CEO Mindy West says the pressure is already baked into full-year guidance and that the White Castle test is too early to judge.

Share
Murphy USA CEO On QuickChek: 'To Be Quite Candid,' Pressure Will Persist

Murphy USA's QuickCheck convenience chain "does continue to face pressure," CEO Mindy West said on the company's third-quarter earnings call, and she expects it to last. The company, which sells fuel and convenience goods through about 1,800 stores, has already built that pressure into its full-year outlook, she said.

A food-forward chain under strain

Asked by a KeyBanc analyst about QuickCheck's performance and EBITDA outlook, West said the company does not break out the unit's EBITDA. She described it as food-forward rather than fuel-forward, a higher-cost model to run, and one with a geographic footprint concentrated in a few markets, so it lacks the cushion of stores elsewhere when competition heats up in one place.

"To be quite candid, we expect all the pressures that we have been seeing and are seeing to continue to persist in the near term," West said. That expectation is reflected in guidance, she added: "So no additional increment."

Her fixes: sharper pricing, a better assortment, stronger food and beverage execution, and labor and operating costs aligned more tightly with customer demand. She also plans to bring the sales-first model used at Murphy USA stores, with upselling and better promotions, to QuickCheck.

As of December 31, 2025, Murphy USA ran 151 QuickChek stores in New Jersey and New York, alongside 1,649 Murphy USA and Murphy Express stores.

White Castle test passes 100 units

West said the White Castle partnership, which the company calls MARS internally (Murphy Automated Restaurant Solutions), has more than 100 units in the market. Murphy USA is deliberately expanding it into new markets and formats as a test, aiming to build evidence on customer demand, fit with its operating model and store-level economics.

It is too early to comment on scalable performance, she said, though the initial results are encouraging. She hopes to offer more detail on future calls.

Margins and a stronger fuel read

Merchandise unit margin was 20.3% in the third quarter, versus 21.5% a year earlier, the company reported.

On fuel, West said October volumes are running at 100% of last year despite hurricanes that shut a large share of stores for several days. She said Murphy USA took share on both total and same-store gallons in the third quarter.

On the pipeline, the company has opened 18 stores year to date, has 55 under construction and plans to start 15 to 20 more by the end of January. It still expects about 45 to 50 openings this year.

West closed the call saying the company is pleased with its results so far this year and will update investors again next quarter.

Sources

More on Murphy USA

All Murphy USA (MUSA) coverage →