Murphy USA CEO: Even If The War Ended Today, Tight Fuel Supply Lasts 'Well Into 2027'

CEO Mindy West says refinery maintenance and supply-chain repair would prolong volatility, which she calls an edge for the fuel retailer.

Share
Murphy USA CEO: Even If The War Ended Today, Tight Fuel Supply Lasts 'Well Into 2027'

Murphy USA, which sells fuel and convenience merchandise through about 1,800 stores, expects tight supply and volatile prices to outlast any end to the war, CEO Mindy West told analysts on the company's earnings call. She called that backdrop an opportunity for the company.

Months, not weeks, to normalize

Even if the war "actually ended today, we would still have lingering impacts well into 2027," West said. She added that this "works to our advantage" because Murphy USA is not dependent on one source of supply and can buy from many places.

Asked by an analyst what would signal a return to normal, West pointed to whether the war truly ends or is just talk, the state of infrastructure overseas, and North American refineries that have run flat out for almost two years and will need maintenance. None of that will normalize within a week or two, she said; it will take months.

On supply, she said that in a normal environment the company expects to earn two to three cents a gallon from the parts it controls, and that tight markets are where its sourcing options pay most, so it expects to earn more than that. RIN prices, the credits embedded in fuel costs, are largely a pass-through, she said.

Margins and the 28-cent benchmark

A Wells Fargo analyst asked where retail margins might settle against the 28 cents earned in 2024 and 2025. West did not give a figure. She said tight supply and volatility should carry into next year, that squeezing marginal competitors lifts margins for everyone, and that stores opening next year will arrive into a favorable environment.

Retail margin in the third quarter came within a penny of the prior year despite prices that rose for almost the whole quarter, she said. Murphy USA's volumes were flat in October so far at 100% of the prior year, despite hurricanes that shut a large share of stores for several days.

The store-opening gap

West said Murphy USA has 18 stores open year to date, 55 under construction and a plan to start 15 to 20 more by the end of January. Guidance of 45 to 50 openings for the year holds.

Had the company opened 50 stores a year from 2021 to 2024, she said, last year's EBITDA would have exceeded $1.1 billion. It opened 18, 35, 22 and 29 stores in those years.

Shares stood at $538.24 in Thursday trading, up 4.46% from the prior close, for a market value of about $9.5 billion.

West said she looks forward to unpacking fourth-quarter results on the January call.

Sources

More on Murphy USA

All Murphy USA (MUSA) coverage →