Kinsale Plans $100 Million A Quarter In Buybacks While Premiums Shrink 4.8%
The insurer's finance chief says he has "no interest in M&A" and sees excess capital, as gross written premium fell in the third quarter.
Kinsale Capital, the specialty insurer, plans to keep buying back about $100 million of its stock each quarter, Chief Financial Officer Chris Tangard said on the company's third-quarter earnings call Friday. Gross written premium fell 4.8% in the quarter, and Tangard said flatly: "We have no interest in M&A."
A $100 million quarterly pace
Kinsale bought back 269,000 shares for $100 million in the third quarter, just under 80% of net operating earnings, Tangard said. That matched the second quarter and compared with $62.5 million in the first quarter. "At this time, we expect $100 million to be a good quarterly run rate," he said, adding that the company plans to be opportunistic otherwise.
Asked by a Jefferies analyst whether the pace extends into 2027, Tangard said it was meant to cover the remainder of the current repurchase authorization. Pressed by a Truist analyst on what follows, CEO Michael Kehoe said the decision would come later. Growth is the top priority, he said, and if it cannot come quickly, "it's buybacks and then, you know, the small dividend."
Tangard said debt is about 10% of total capitalization, and that if more capital is needed, Kinsale would likely use leverage to generate higher returns on equity.
Growth slows as big accounts shrink
Net written premium fell 1.5%, and the company said competition in commercial property weighed on growth. Excluding that division, gross written premium was down half a percent. Kehoe said submissions, quotes and bind orders grew in the mid single-digit range, as the book shifted from larger to smaller accounts.
The combined ratio, a measure of underwriting profit in which lower is better, was 75.4%, against 74.9% a year earlier. Diluted operating earnings per share rose 9.4%, to $5.70, while diluted earnings per share fell 28.4%.
Kinsale writes only excess and surplus lines coverage, insurance for risks that are unusual or hard to place with standard insurers, mainly for small and medium-sized businesses.
A $37.6 million bond-sale loss
The drop in standard earnings came mainly from portfolio repositioning. Kinsale sold bonds at a loss and equities at a gain, and the net pre-tax hit was $37.6 million, or $1.67 per diluted share, Tangard said. The sales had no impact on book value.
The company replaced about $130 million of bonds yielding less than 2% with bonds yielding more than 5.5%. Tangard told a JPMorgan analyst that should add roughly $5.5 million to $6 million a year. Net investment income rose 17.5% to $58.3 million.
Kinsale's market value was $8.9 billion in Friday morning trading, as the company works to grow into a softer market with a buyback running at $100 million a quarter.
Sources
- Here's What Key Metrics Tell Us About Kinsale Capital Group (KNSL) Q3 Earnings — Yahoo Finance
- Kinsale Cap Gr Q3 2026 Earnings Call Transcript — benzinga.com
- Kinsale Capital Non-GAAP EPS of $5.70 beats by $0.59, revenue of $454.8M misses by $22.36M (NYSE:KNSL) | Seeking Alpha — seekingalpha.com
- Kinsale Capital Group Reports Third Quarter 2026 Results — Yahoo Finance
- Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. (KNSL) Q3 Earnings Surpass Estimates — Yahoo Finance