Kinsale CEO Cites A $120,000 Renewal Rewritten For $30,000: 'We're Not Going To Chase That Down'

Kinsale's premium fell 4.8% in the third quarter, but its CEO said submissions, quotes and bind orders rose in the mid single-digit range.

Share
Kinsale CEO Cites A $120,000 Renewal Rewritten For $30,000: 'We're Not Going To Chase That Down'

Kinsale Capital CEO Michael Kehoe said on the company's earnings call Friday that a competitor wrote a $120,000 renewal for $30,000 last week, and that Kinsale will not match that kind of pricing. Gross written premium fell 4.8% in the third quarter, a drop Kehoe called temporary and said "correct near-term on its own."

Wild behavior on big accounts

Kinsale Capital, which writes excess and surplus lines insurance, the market for risks that standard insurers find hard to place, is losing ground at the top of its book. Kehoe said policies of $100,000 in premium and up are 0.7% of its policies but about 12% of premium. He said Kinsale sees lower hit ratios on new-business quotes and lower renewal retention on those accounts.

Then came the anecdote. "Somebody wrote it for $30,000," Kehoe said of the $120,000 renewal, adding "there's some wild behavior out there. Obviously, we're not going to chase that down." To offset a $120,000 policy, he said, Kinsale has to write 10 policies of $12,000.

Chief Underwriting Officer Stuart Winston told a Jefferies analyst the same pressure shows up in long-tail casualty, where fronting carriers and managing general agents are pricing larger deals. Accounts that should be $500,000 are going for $150,000, he said, and "it's just not worth competing on that business." Winston said that has been going on for a couple of years.

Fewer big accounts, more small ones

Kehoe said submissions, quotes and bind orders all grew in the mid single-digit range, as the book shifted from larger to smaller accounts. Excluding the commercial property division, gross written premium was down half a percent. Net written premium fell 1.5%, and the combined ratio, a measure of underwriting profit in which lower is better, was 75.4% against 74.9% a year earlier.

Kehoe said he expects the mix shift to run its course quickly and a return to modest growth "hopefully in the near term," though he said he couldn't give a date. Diluted operating earnings per share rose 9.4% to $5.70, while diluted earnings per share fell 28.4% after bond sales in a loss position that had a net pre-tax impact of $37.6 million, or $1.67 per share.

Kinsale repurchased 269,000 shares for $100 million in the quarter. CFO Chris Tangard said $100 million is a good quarterly run rate for the remainder of the repurchase authorization.

Shares slide on the day

Kinsale shares fell 5.76% to $368.12 in Friday trading, as of the 10:31 a.m. ET reading, for a market value of $8.9 billion.

Winston said pricing across Kinsale's book is in line with the AmWins index, which fell 3.1% against a 5.9% decrease in the second quarter. He said new-business submissions rose 6%, or 10% excluding commercial property.

Asked whether the pressure would ease, Winston said there are signs commercial property reductions are easing, but "it's day by day."

Sources

More on Kinsale Capital

All Kinsale Capital (KNSL) coverage →