Invitation Homes Sold Houses At $460,000 While Its Buybacks Value Them At $280,000
The landlord has repurchased nearly $1 billion of stock and added a $500 million program, but its CFO says sale proceeds don't convert one for one.
Invitation Homes sold homes at an average gross price of about $460,000 since last December, while its own buyback prices imply the market values each home at $280,000, CEO Dallas Tanner said on the company's third-quarter earnings call Thursday. The board has just authorized a new $500 million repurchase program, and Tanner called the gap proof the company acts on its view that the stock is undervalued.
Nearly $1 billion of buybacks
Invitation Homes, which owns and leases single-family homes across the United States, has repurchased nearly $1 billion of its stock, about 6% of shares outstanding, Tanner said. "It's one thing to say our stock is undervalued, it's another to act on it again and again," he told analysts.
CFO John Olsen put the total at about 37 million shares for $989 million, an average of $26.78 a share, through Tuesday. That includes 8.9 million shares bought for $250 million in the third quarter. Tanner said he believes the company has bought back more stock than any other residential REIT.
The company intends to keep funding repurchases with home sale proceeds whenever the stock trades at a meaningful discount to the value of its homes, Tanner said.
Sales fund the repurchases
In the third quarter Invitation Homes sold 658 wholly owned homes for gross proceeds of about $318 million, an average of about $484,000 a home, Olsen said. Net of 216 homes it acquired, mostly builder deliveries, net proceeds were about $245 million.
Through September the company had sold $833 million of homes, against a raised disposition guidance midpoint of $950 million, Tanner said. The range is now $900 million to $1 billion, up $100 million at the midpoint. Core FFO (funds from operations, a REIT earnings measure) per share rose 2.4% to 48 cents, and full-year guidance moved up a penny at the midpoint to $1.94 to $1.98.
Why the program isn't bigger
A KeyBanc analyst asked why the company doesn't enlarge the program given the earnings accretion. Olsen said selling homes shrinks EBITDA and the company distributes gains, so "sale proceeds don't convert dollar for dollar into buybacks." Leverage and market conditions are the two guideposts, he said. Net debt to adjusted EBITDA was 5.5 times, inside its 5.5 to 6 times target range.
Tanner said anything beyond buybacks "has to be really compelling," and called repurchases the most compelling use of capital over the past four quarters. Olsen said tax capacity is one factor in sizing sales and buybacks, and 2027 plans will come with guidance in February. Scott McLaughlin, the company's head of investor relations, said the fourth quarter is its slowest selling season.
Olsen said the company will lay out its 2027 sales and buyback plans, including tax capacity, when it issues guidance in February.
Sources
- Compared to Estimates, Invitation Home (INVH) Q3 Earnings: A Look at Key Metrics — Yahoo Finance
- Document — sec.gov
- Invitation Homes Says Bd Authorizes $500M of New Share Buybacks — MarketWatch
- With more corporate investors controlling metro Atlanta housing, researchers call for legal protections - CBS Atlanta — CBS News
- Invitation Homes Reports Third Quarter 2026 Results — businesswire.com