Asbury CEO Says Stock Price Ignores What Private Buyers Pay For Dealerships
Dan Clara pointed to owned real estate and the warranty unit, while the CFO put debt paydown ahead of buybacks.
Asbury Automotive Group CEO Dan Clara said on the company's third-quarter earnings call Tuesday that its share price does not reflect what private buyers are paying for dealership portfolios. The franchised auto retailer, whose adjusted earnings of $6.16 a share trailed $7.17 a year earlier, says acquisitions wait until it pays down debt.
Clara's case for a higher valuation
Asked about M&A by an analyst from Barclays, Clara said private-market deals "continue to show the value that buyers place on high quality dealership portfolios." He said Asbury "stacks up very well" with its mix of luxury and import franchises.
He pointed to owned real estate: "we own over 80% of our real estate." He also cited Total Care Auto, the warranty and service-contract unit, which he said the market does not fully credit.
His conclusion: "our current share price does not reflect the underlying value of the business that we're seeing in some of these private markets deals that are going out there." Asbury's shares were down 26% year to date, according to the Associated Press, with a market value of $3.1 billion at the time of the report.
Debt first, then buybacks
Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Michael Welch ranked the uses of cash when David Winston of Morningstar asked about funding tuck-in deals. Leverage comes first, then buybacks at the current share price, then small acquisitions. Once leverage is down, he said, buybacks and tuck-ins should be doable with free cash flow.
Asbury ended the quarter with a net leverage ratio of 3.5 times. The goal of three times is targeted by mid-2027. "Right now, you know, we're just a little limited in terms of where the leverage is," Welch said.
A software rollout finally done
Asbury, which owned 171 dealership locations at the end of 2025, now runs every store on the Tekion software platform. It converted 47 stores in the quarter and the last 10 in October. Clara said the time and resources spent on the rollout can now go back to running the business.
The quarter brought $4.4 billion in revenue and $732 million in gross profit. Adjusted EBITDA was $218 million. A non-cash deferral at Total Care Auto cost 69 cents a share; without it, adjusted earnings would have been $6.85.
Clara also said the Federal Trade Commission's administrative proceeding against the company was dismissed in early October.
Management says it plans to reach three times net leverage by mid-2027, the point at which buybacks and tuck-in deals come back into play.
Sources
- Asbury Automotive: Q3 Earnings Snapshot — Associated Press
- Asbury Automotive Group (ABG) Misses Q3 Earnings and Revenue Estimates — Yahoo Finance
- Asbury Automotive Group Reports Third Quarter Results – Company Announcement - FT.com — Financial Times