Asbury CEO Says Service Advisors Are Discounting While They Learn New Software

Dan Clara tied thinner repair margins and a 1.9% drop in customer-paid repair orders to the Tekion rollout and pointed to late first-quarter relief.

Share
Asbury CEO Says Service Advisors Are Discounting While They Learn New Software

Asbury Automotive Group, the franchised dealership chain, is giving up service margin while its staff learns new software, CEO Dan Clara said on the company's third-quarter earnings call Tuesday. Advisors used to an old system, he said, "start discounting" to keep waiting customers moving, and customer-paid repair orders fell 1.9% in the quarter.

Discounts at the service desk

Answering an analyst from Seaport Research Partners, Clara said advisors who had spent 20 or 30 years processing customers one way under CDK now face five or six people waiting while they learn Tekion. "The path of least resistance," he said, is to discount. As muscle memory builds, he said, the discounts fade and margins return to normal.

Asked by a Bank of America analyst whether customers are drifting to cheaper independent shops, Clara said declined work has not risen. He said he would not "make a big deal about" the 1.9% dip, calling it seasonality plus the disruption of converting 47 stores in the quarter, the heaviest lift of the rollout.

Overall, he said, parts and service "was not where we wanted it to be." Customer-pay revenue rose 2% with gross profit flat, and warranty gross profit fell 1%.

Six months to muscle memory

Asbury has now moved every active store to Tekion, finishing the last 10 dealerships in October. Clara said its longest-running stores, in Georgia and a second market the transcript renders as "Coons," posted customer-pay gross profit up 7% in the third quarter, against flat for the company's same stores. Total fixed-operations gross grew 5% there, versus a 2% decline companywide.

Clara said the 35 to 40 stores in those markets have passed the six-month mark. Florida, which just crossed it, saw fixed-operations gross profit up 3% in September.

The 47 stores converted in the quarter will not reach that point until the end of the first quarter, he said, so full benefit comes "the tail end of Q1, beginning of Q2."

What management expects for 2027

Same-store adjusted SG&A, or overhead, ran 67% of gross profit in the quarter. CFO Michael Welch said fixed operations should return to growth in the mid-single-digit range next year, with SG&A starting around the mid-60s and ending 2027 in the low 60s. He said half of that improvement comes from gross profit growth and half from cost cuts.

The company, which owns dealerships and a finance and insurance product unit called Total Care Auto, posted $4.4 billion in revenue and adjusted earnings of $6.16 a share, which Welch said would have been $6.85 without a 69-cent non-cash deferral tied to Total Care Auto. Net leverage was 3.5 times, and Welch said the company plans to reach its target of 3 times by mid-2027.

Clara said the company is "not going to realize the full benefit" of Tekion until the end of the first quarter and into the second quarter of 2027.

Sources

More on Asbury Automotive Group

All Asbury Automotive Group (ABG) coverage →