Ally's CFO Says Stellantis Lease Losses, Including A $16 Million Hit, Will Persist Into Fourth Quarter
Ally still sees fourth-quarter margin around 3.7% and full-year margin of 3.6% to 3.65%, even as lease returns cost it margin.
Ally Financial's lease yields absorbed a $16 million loss on lease terminations in the third quarter, CFO Russ Hutchinson said on the company's earnings call, and he expects the pressure from Stellantis vehicles to last into the fourth quarter.
What the CFO said about leases
Hutchinson tied the loss to "continued pressure on Stellantis auction prices and residual values" from a broader brand and recall-related overhang. Given the mix of leases now coming up for termination, he said the pressure should persist into the fourth quarter.
He expects the headwind to abate through 2027 as the lease portfolio moves toward a more diversified mix of automakers. Since Ally announced a partnership with a battery electric automaker in March 2024, he said, about half of its lease origination volume includes residual value guarantees, which reduces the part of the portfolio exposed to swings in used-vehicle values.
Net interest margin, excluding original issue discount, was 3.66%, up three basis points from the second quarter. Hutchinson said deposit pricing actions were largely offset by the lease termination losses.
Margin outlook and the precision caveat
Pressed by a Goldman Sachs analyst on whether margin could hold, Hutchinson said the Stellantis returns have "cost us more than a few basis points" this quarter. He still guided to a fourth-quarter margin around 3.7% and a full-year range of 3.6% to 3.65%.
He cautioned against reading that with basis-point precision. On the quarter's net financing revenue, he said, $4 million can move margin by a basis point.
He also said the balance sheet is slightly asset sensitive near term, because roughly $60 billion of floating-rate exposures will reprice higher. That benefit moderates as retail deposits reprice, and he said it turns liability sensitive over the medium term.
The rest of the quarter
CEO Michael Rhodes said adjusted earnings per share of $1.34 rose 16% from a year earlier, on adjusted net revenue of $2.3 billion, up 9%. Ally decisioned 4.8 million auto applications, up 20%, and originated $12.9 billion, up 10%.
Hutchinson said the company now expects average earning assets to grow 5% to 6% this year, up from 3% to 5% previously. He said Ally announced a quarterly dividend of $0.35 for the fourth quarter, its first increase since 2022.
On credit, he said late 2025 and early 2026 vintages show higher early-life delinquency, but that full-year credit is tracking the middle of guidance. He said 2027 net charge-offs should look a lot like 2026.
The next test is the fourth quarter: Ally has guided to a margin around 3.7% and a full-year margin of 3.6% to 3.65%, with Stellantis lease pressure still in the numbers.