VICI Authorizes Its First Buyback, Up To $2 Billion — And Its CEO Says He's 'Disappointed' In The Stock
CEO Ed Pitoniak says he never ruled out repurchases, while the CFO says most free cash flow is already spoken for by loan commitments.
VICI Properties, the REIT that owns casinos and resorts and leases them to operators, has authorized its first stock buyback, for up to $2 billion, and CEO Ed Pitoniak said on the company's third-quarter earnings call Thursday that he is "disappointed" with the share price this quarter and year to date. CFO David Kieske called the program a tool, not a commitment.
A tool, not a commitment
Kieske said the authorization gives VICI flexibility but does not obligate it to buy any specific amount or on any timeline. Pitoniak stressed the same condition: if the company has uncommitted investable capital, it will weigh uses and may buy stock if that is the best one.
Asked whether a buyback would compete with the deal pipeline, Kieske said most free cash flow is currently allocated to loan commitments. The program, he said, is there for excess cash that may arise at some point in the future.
A Scotiabank analyst argued that current commitments imply excess free cash flow in 2027. Kieske replied that VICI sees debt investments yielding above its AFFO yield (adjusted funds from operations, a REIT earnings measure), and said a buyback, like an at-the-market equity program, is simply one tool.
"I don't think I ever used the word never"
Pitoniak took aim at analyst notes published the night before, which he said construed VICI as having vowed never to repurchase shares. "I don't think I ever used the word never," he said, adding that VICI has "never, ever ruled out share buybacks."
He listed three funding sources that do not rely on public equity: retained cash flow after all obligations, which averages about $720 million on a trailing 12-month basis, loan repayments, and asset sales. Gabe Wasserman, managing director of business development at VICI, pointed to the Fontainebleau loan, which faces an extension test in January of 2027 and matures in 2028, as money that could come back and be redeployed, including into buybacks.
Quarter and balance sheet
Pitoniak cited three factors weighing on the stock: weakness in net lease REITs, VICI's ability to grow accretively at its current cost of capital, and uncertainty over its Caesars regional lease. VICI owned 93 properties as of December 31, 2025, with Caesars its largest tenant at 39% of annualized rent.
Third-quarter revenue grew 5.8% and AFFO per share rose 4.3% to 62 cents, from 60 cents a year earlier. Kieske said VICI raised 2026 AFFO guidance to between $2.47 and $2.48 per diluted share.
Net debt is about 4.8 times annualized adjusted EBITDA, below the company's 5 to 5.5 times target range.
$1.5 billion due in February
Kieske said VICI plans to refinance $1.5 billion of notes due in February, possibly later this year or early next. He cited $7.2 billion of orders for its $1.75 billion August bond sale as evidence that fixed-income investors see its cash flows as stable.
Pitoniak closed the call by saying VICI looks forward to talking with investors again in February, the month the $1.5 billion of notes comes due.
Sources
- VICI Properties (VICI) Q3 Earnings: Taking a Look at Key Metrics Versus Estimates — Yahoo Finance
- VICI Properties Q3 revenue beats, but earnings in line as expenses rise (VICI:NYSE) | Seeking Alpha — seekingalpha.com
- VICI Properties Inc. (VICI) Q3 FFO Meet Estimates — Yahoo Finance
- Should Buyback And Dividend Boost Require Action From Vici Properties (VICI) Investors? — Yahoo Finance
- VICI Properties (VICI) Lifted AFFO Guidance, Is It Still 44% Below Fair Value? — Yahoo Finance