Upstart CEO Says Investors Are 'Wrong About The Stock' But Have 'Every Right' To Doubt It
Paul Gu says 14 years without meaningful profits explain the skepticism, as Upstart trims its 2026 revenue and adjusted EBITDA outlook.
Upstart co-founder and CEO Paul Gu said on the company's third-quarter earnings call Tuesday that investors undervalue the stock but have earned the right to, and the company cut its 2026 revenue and profit outlook in the same session. Upstart, which runs an online lending marketplace that uses its own AI models to decide who gets approved for loans and at what rate, now expects about $1.35 billion in total revenue and about $260 million in adjusted EBITDA.
A CEO concedes the skeptics' case
Answering a question submitted by a retail investor, who asked what would force the market to stop valuing Upstart like a cyclical lender, Gu said: "I think investors are wrong about the stock. I think they're undervaluing the stock."
He then gave the other side. Investors "have every right to do that because they can't tell if and when we're finally going to make some real money," he said.
Gu put the skeptic's view as a question: "what's the point of all this fancy AI if it doesn't make money?" Upstart has been around 14 years without meaningful profits, he said, and "I don't think we get to complain about how investors are valuing us yet."
Upstart shares traded about 2% lower at $20.79 in Tuesday trading, from a prior close of $21.31.
The guidance cut, line by line
In February, Upstart guided to $1.4 billion in total revenue and $294 million in adjusted EBITDA. Gu said that outlook assumed the Upstart Macro Index, the company's estimate of how economic conditions affect defaults on its personal loans, went no higher than 1.5, with interest rates flat or down.
The index has since climbed from 1.39 to 1.53, he said, while the two-year Treasury yield rose by more than 115 basis points through the end of October.
CFO Andrea Blankmeyer said the reduction reflects lower net interest income and fair value adjustments, driven mainly by the higher index. Fee revenue and contribution profit, the company's measure of profit on new loans, are now seen modestly above original guidance. She put full-year fee revenue at about $1.32 billion and contribution profit at $750 million.
The new outlook assumes the index stays at or below 1.55 through year-end and that two-year Treasury yields do not change materially.
Alpha, beta and the balance sheet
Gu framed the results with a formula: growth equals alpha plus beta times macro. Alpha is progress from technology and marketing; beta is how sensitive balance-sheet income is to the economy.
Third-quarter contribution profit hit a record $218 million, which Blankmeyer said was up 48% from a year earlier. Gu said it would have grown at least 61% without the rise in the macro index.
He argued beta is already falling. Loans on Upstart's own balance sheet were 4.8% of loans outstanding in the quarter, and outstanding loans grew 38% over the past year while equity use rose 7%.
Upstart Bank is on track to open in early 2027, subject to remaining regulatory approvals, Gu said. Blankmeyer said capitalizing it would take about $404.1 million in cash and servicing assets.
October originations were about $1.25 billion, Blankmeyer said, with daily volume down 9% from September and up 26% from a year earlier.
Sources
- Upstart (NASDAQ:UPST) posts better-than-expected sales in Q3 2026, stock soars — Yahoo Finance
- Upstart Holdings, Inc. (UPST) Surpasses Q3 Earnings and Revenue Estimates — Yahoo Finance
- Upstart reports Q3 earnings above expectations; guides on 2026 with caution (UPST:NASDAQ) — seekingalpha.com
- Upstart Shares Are Retreating Tuesday: What's Happening? — benzinga.com
- Upstart GAAP EPS of $0.33 beats by $0.10, revenue of $371M beats by $7.3M; updates FY outl — seekingalpha.com