Unum's Disability Claims Jumped 10% Above Plan, And Management Can't Say If It Lasts

The insurer's group disability benefit ratio hit 70.6% from 61.3% a year earlier, and executives would not call the spike cyclical or structural.

Share
Unum's Disability Claims Jumped 10% Above Plan, And Management Can't Say If It Lasts

Unum Group, which sells workplace insurance such as disability and life coverage through employers, said on its third-quarter earnings call that long-term disability claim submissions ran about 10% above expectations, pushing its group disability benefit ratio to 70.6% from 61.3% a year ago. Chief Financial Officer Steve Zabel said the rise "was not" expected, and CEO Rick McKinney said it is "hard to actually predict whether it's cyclical or not."

Five points from one claim type

Zabel said long-term disability submissions added about five points of pressure to the group disability ratio, while short-term disability and paid family and medical leave added about two. Of the leave trend he said, "the increase in LTD submissions was not" the part anyone saw coming; the leave trend was largely expected.

The surge was concentrated in behavioral health claims, Zabel said, and submissions through the second quarter had been right at expectations. Early in the fourth quarter, he said, the elevated level had not reverted, though he called it very early and noted these claims are volatile within a quarter.

After-tax adjusted operating earnings were $2.20 per share, including $0.33 of favorable notable items, against $2.81 a year earlier that included $0.75. Unum now expects full-year adjusted earnings of $8.30 to $8.50 per share, including about $0.33 from notable items. Zabel said the definition of the measure was revised after discussions with SEC staff, so the annual reserve review now flows into it.

What analysts pushed on

An analyst at Evercore ISI asked whether the 70.6% assumes lower approval rates, as past surges have produced. Zabel said Unum uses its normal acceptance rate, so no favorability is built in. Submissions do not necessarily become paid claims, he said, and it is premature to say how they are converting.

A Jefferies analyst argued the 65% long-term benefit ratio target may not help and suggested ranges. Zabel said the claims dynamic was "obviously unforeseen" but Unum remains committed to that level, and will have to "take some action" to get there.

On 2027, Zabel said the company will not comment until its outlook meeting in the first quarter of next year. He said the current outlook assumes earnings levels consistent with the third quarter.

Repricing after giving back rate

Chris Pyne, who leads group benefits, said Unum had cut rates during favorable disability years and now has the credibility to seek them back. McKinney said the pressure comes from more people submitting claims, not from competition or changes in how Unum adjudicates. Leave pricing is being raised by double digits.

Beyond group insurance, the UK saw a benefit ratio of 80.5% against 73.8% a year ago. On capital, Zabel put the traditional risk-based capital ratio at 485% and holding company liquidity at $1.4 billion. Unum bought back about $200 million of stock in the quarter and still aims to return $1.3 billion for the year. It also closed a second long-term care reinsurance deal with Fortitude REIT, ceding $3.8 billion of statutory reserves.

The stock

Unum shares were at $75.06, down about 18% from the previous close, in the session on the day of the report, giving the company a market value of $14.4 billion.

McKinney told analysts that cycles "are things you'll look back on," leaving the fourth-quarter submission trend as the next read on whether the spike holds.

Sources

More on Unum Group

All Unum Group (UNM) coverage →