Union Pacific CEO Tells Analysts 'There Is No Santa Claus' For Rivals Wanting Merger Concessions
Jim Vena says he is "99.999 sure" the Norfolk Southern deal wins approval, and that Union Pacific will walk away from a bad one.
Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena said on the railroad's third-quarter earnings call that he is "99.999 sure" the Norfolk Southern merger will be approved, and that rivals asking for concessions should know "there is no Santa Claus." He also warned that "we will walk away from this" if the terms turn bad for the company.
Santa Claus, poker and a walk-away line
Asked by a Wells Fargo analyst whether further agreements could head off competitors' demands, Vena, who is chairman, president and chief executive, said any request must be "fact based" on its impact. He argued that the Surface Transportation Board, the federal regulator reviewing the deal, handed other railroads no concessions when it approved the Canadian Pacific and Kansas City merger, because that combination had little overlap.
A Barclays analyst pressed on whether more deals could smooth approval. Vena likened the process to poker, saying you don't show your hand before the last card. "If anybody thinks we're going to make a bad deal for Union Pacific, we're not," he said. He added that he is waiting to see what filers put in by the November 18 comment deadline, "and then at that point, we'll re-examine." He also said "I don't see us making a deal with anybody," though he would talk if people become reasonable.
On a Wolfe Research analyst's question about a separate note from one of the four board members after the application advanced, Vena joked he wondered whether the member "used AI to summarize the 8,000 pages" of the application. Vena said the board has published a procedural schedule under which Union Pacific should report its first earnings as a merged company a year from now. The railroad has asked for the second time for ex parte communications, meaning private talks, with the board.
Berkshire, unions and customers
Vena said Berkshire, which owns BNSF, has been "pretty black and white" against a merger. He said he sat through a seven-hour deposition with its lawyers, and that he would have no problem if CSX and BNSF merged.
He said more than 500 customers have written letters of support, and that few if any have filed opposition with the board. On labor, he said no one in the industry has guaranteed unionized employees jobs for life, and called the Teamsters' place in the opposing coalition surprising.
A record quarter behind the fight
Union Pacific, which runs a freight railroad across 23 western states, reported net income of $2.1 billion and adjusted earnings of $3.53 a share, up 15%. Operating revenue was $7.2 billion, up 15%, on 6% volume growth. Chief Financial Officer Jennifer Hamner said higher fuel prices weighed on margins, with the operating ratio at 58.8%.
Hamner said the company is building cash ahead of closing the Norfolk Southern merger in the second half of 2027. It affirmed its 2026 outlook of high single-digit growth in reported earnings per share. Union Pacific shares rose 2.00% to $293.64 in Thursday trading, according to market data.
Vena said he will see what rivals and others formally file by November 18 before deciding whether anything has been missed.
Sources
- Railroad revenues get a boost from trucking disruptions, but fuel costs weigh on margins (UNP:NYSE) | Seeking Alpha — seekingalpha.com
- Union Pacific’s (NYSE:UNP) Q3 2026 sales beat estimates — Yahoo Finance
- Union Pacific (UNP) Tops Q3 Earnings and Revenue Estimates — Yahoo Finance
- US Railroad Operator Union Pacific's Quarterly Profit Rises — Reuters
- Union Pacific Gears Up to Report Q3 Earnings: Is a Beat in Store? — Yahoo Finance