Stifel CEO On Merging With A Bigger Firm: Scale In A People Business Brings 'Diseconomies Of Scale'
Ron Kruszewski answered a valuation-gap question by saying a combination with weaker-metric firm would not earn a higher multiple.
Stifel Chairman and CEO Ron Kruszewski said on the company's third-quarter earnings call Wednesday that combining with a firm that has weaker financial metrics would not earn Stifel a higher multiple. A BMO Capital Markets analyst had asked whether partnering with a larger firm could close the gap, which Kruszewski's own slide put at nine times forward earnings for Stifel.
The valuation gap and the merger question
Kruszewski opened the call by reviving a peer slide the firm last used about four years ago. It showed Stifel at nine times forward earnings, against 10.2 for Raymond James and 13 for Morgan Stanley.
He said earnings per share are up 406% since the end of 2016 and tangible book value is up 154%, both better than either peer. Return on tangible common equity over the last 12 months, he said, is more than 26%, the highest of the three. "The numbers don't support the valuation gap that I see," he told analysts, in words close to that effect on the call.
The BMO Capital Markets analyst asked whether Stifel would consider partnering to join a larger, more scaled organization to bridge the gap. Kruszewski called it "a fair question" and "just a long way of asking it."
If Stifel were to scale, he said, it would want a partner with higher margins, returns and growth. On whether combining with weaker metrics would earn a higher multiple, he said: "The answer is no." Most institutions that try to combine for scale in a people business, he added, "find out that those lead to diseconomies of scale, not economies of scale."
Buybacks, not deals
A JPMorgan analyst asked whether large acquisitions are off the table and whether buybacks might grow if the disconnect persists. Kruszewski said there is an attractive acquisition out there: "It's called our own stock."
He said that if he announced a purchase at 15 to 18 times EBITDA, earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, "the street wouldn't react well."
CFO Jim said the pace of buybacks slowed in the quarter. Stifel repurchased 1.6 million shares while growing loans by $1.3 billion, he said, and ended with nearly $360 million of excess capital and 6.2 million shares left on its authorization.
The quarter and the outlook
Third-quarter earnings per share were $1.46, up 12% from a year earlier, on net revenue of $1.43 billion. Kruszewski said September's rate increase, the Fed's first in three years, unsettled markets and slowed the institutional business. Shares traded at $66.24, down 0.88% from the prior close of $66.83, in Wednesday trading; a Yahoo Finance report put the stock down about 20% this year.
Kruszewski said he expects fourth-quarter revenue to match last year's record $1.56 billion. Jim said management will return next quarter with more detail on its 2027 outlook.
Stifel will report fourth-quarter results next, with the 2027 outlook promised then; Kruszewski has said he expects revenue to match last year's $1.56 billion.
Sources
- Stifel Financial (SF) Q3 Earnings Beat Estimates — Yahoo Finance
- Stifel Financial (SF) Could Be 23% Undervalued Before Wednesday Earnings — Yahoo Finance
- Stifel Financial (SF) Stock Still Looks Like A Bargain As Its 82% Run Fades — Yahoo Finance
- Stifel: Q3 Earnings Snapshot – WTOP News — wtop.com
- Stifel Financial Non-GAAP EPS of $1.46 beats by $0.01, revenue of $1.43B misses by $20M (SF:NYSE) — seekingalpha.com