Sonic Automotive President Says A 'Motivational Call' Held New-Car Margins At $3,048 A Vehicle
Jeff Dyke tied the push to FTC pricing rules and said he wants regulators to punish rivals still playing games.
Sonic Automotive, the US car retailer, held new-vehicle profit at $3,048 a unit in the third quarter, and President Jeff Dyke said on Thursday's earnings call that a "motivational call" to sales managers after the second quarter is why. Dyke said rivals' margins had been dropping $150, $200 and $300 a car, and he wants the Federal Trade Commission to hit those still breaking its rules harder.
A line in the sand on margins
Asked by an analyst why Sonic's new-car profit per unit bucked the industry, Dyke pointed to the FTC's pricing actions. He said the company changed the mindset of its sales managers, adding that "sometimes gross is a state of mind."
Pressed by a Citi analyst, Dyke said Sonic "drew a line in the sand" and adjusted compensation plans across multiple positions. The effort began after the second quarter and continued in October, he said, and was not a "two-month whim." It was not brand-specific, he said, though Honda did best.
CEO David Smith said reported new-vehicle profit per unit rose 2% from a year earlier, while the same-store figure was flat at $3,000. Dyke said the company is narrowing its full-year front-end margin range because he expects the gains to hold.
Volume held, with an EV asterisk
Same-store new unit volume fell 7%, which Smith attributed largely to heavy electric-vehicle exposure at luxury brands and California stores. He estimated last year's EV pull-forward added about 2,200 new retail units in the year-earlier quarter and accounted for a $5 million drop in gross profit. Excluding those units, he said, new retail volume would have been flat.
Danny Wieland, vice president of investor relations, said new volume was essentially flat from the second to the third quarter. Excluding those EVs, he said, same-store volume was up from a year earlier. Smith said Sonic kept its market share.
Dyke wants tougher FTC enforcement
Dyke said the FTC action is pushing competitors toward the same rules, but not everyone yet. He urged third-party lead providers to stop letting people "playing games" appear on their websites. "I don't think the punishments have been strong enough yet," he said, arguing some hand-slapping is needed so everyone knows the agency means business.
He said Sonic is counting on the FTC to hold violators accountable and to end the transparent-pricing debate in the industry.
The rest of the quarter
Sonic reported record quarterly gross profit of $617.5 million and adjusted earnings of $1.30 a share, which Smith gave alongside $1.28 reported. Franchised revenue fell 3% to $3.3 billion. EchoPark revenue rose 14% to $596 million, and Powersports revenue rose 35% to $113.7 million.
Smith said the board approved a 41-cent dividend payable January 15, 2027, and that $528 million remains on the buyback authorization, which management is weighing against acquisitions.
Dyke said October's margins held and that he expects a great fourth quarter.
Sources
- Sonic Automotive Non-GAAP EPS of $1.30 misses by $0.36, revenue of $4B misses by $30M | Seeking Alpha — seekingalpha.com
- Sonic Automotive Reports Third Quarter 2026 Financial Results – Company Announcement - FT.com — Financial Times
- Sonic Automotive (SAH) Misses Q3 Earnings and Revenue Estimates — Yahoo Finance
- Sonic Automotive: Q3 Earnings Snapshot – WTOP News — wtop.com
- Penske Automotive (PAG) Misses Q3 Earnings Estimates — Yahoo Finance