Shopify CFO: Only About 150 Basis Points Of Cash Flow Margin Gain Is Structural

Marketing tests, tax receivable timing and a merchant cash advance accounting change drove the rest, the CFO said.

Share
Shopify CFO: Only About 150 Basis Points Of Cash Flow Margin Gain Is Structural

Shopify's third-quarter free cash flow margin of 22% leaned on temporary items, Chief Financial Officer Jeff Hoffmeister said on the company's earnings call Tuesday, with only about 150 basis points (1.5 percentage points) of the year-over-year improvement coming from lasting discipline. Free cash flow was $816 million, he said.

Three temporary items, roughly equal

Hoffmeister said about 150 basis points of the margin gain came from "structural operating discipline and expense leverage." The rest came from the marketing tests the company ran during the quarter, the timing of certain tax receivables, and an accounting change to merchant cash advances, "each of these three being roughly equally sized."

On marketing, he said "some of the reduced spend will effectively shift to Q4," though "nothing has changed about our marketing approach." Asked by a Piper Sandler analyst whether the tests hurt sales, he answered "no top line impact," saying they ran in some channels and geographies.

Shopify, which provides a commerce platform for merchants to sell online, in store and on channels such as social media and AI platforms, reported third-quarter revenue up 32% to $3.7 billion and gross merchandise volume up 29.5% to $119 billion, President Harley Finkelstein said.

Why the fourth quarter margin may not rise

An Evercore ISI analyst noted that free cash flow margin normally rises from the third quarter to the fourth, and asked why it would not this time. Hoffmeister pointed to the shifted marketing spend, plus holiday-season infrastructure and performance marketing he said has delivered strong returns.

He added that fourth-quarter free cash flow faces higher taxes from payment timing in certain jurisdictions. He said he does not expect any meaningful impact from the merchant cash advance accounting change.

Guidance and the stock

Hoffmeister guided for fourth-quarter revenue growth in the low 30s year over year, with less than a point of currency headwind. He said that would mark a seventh consecutive quarter of revenue growth in the low 30s.

On Sidekick, the company's AI assistant for merchants, he said merchant conversations rose 14% from the second to the third quarter while cost per conversation fell 28%.

Shares were down about 9% at $142.33 in Tuesday trading, against a prior close of $156.22, giving the company a market value of $201.0 billion.

Fourth-quarter results will show how much marketing and holiday infrastructure spend lands against that low-30s revenue growth guide.

Sources

More on Shopify

All Shopify (SHOP) coverage →