Root Posts $14 Million Quarterly Profit, A Year After A Loss, As Premiums Written Fall 8%
The car insurer says it gave up Direct growth that missed its return bar while rivals cut prices, and leaned on Carvana and Hyundai.
Root, which sells car insurance priced largely on how people drive, earned $14 million in the third quarter, against a $5 million net loss a year earlier, even as written premiums fell 8% to $358 million. In its shareholder letter, furnished with an 8-K on Wednesday, the company said larger rivals cut prices and it chose not to chase growth that fell short of its return targets.
Profit up, premiums down
Revenue was $381 million, versus $388 million a year earlier. Adjusted EBITDA, a measure that strips out interest, taxes, depreciation, stock pay and other items, was $34 million, broadly in line with the prior-year period, and the company cited an annualized return on equity of approximately 18%.
The net combined ratio, an insurance cost gauge where lower is better, was 97.2%, improving 4.9 points from a year earlier. The gross accident period loss ratio was 61.1%, inside the company's long-term target range of 60% to 65%.
Gross written premium fell 8% to $358 million and gross earned premium fell 5% to $356 million, which Root tied to lower premium per policy and its restraint in Direct. Policies in force ended the quarter at 484,037, up 4% from a year earlier, while premium per policy slid to $1,441 from $1,581.
Discipline over Direct growth
Root said personal auto competition intensified, with large carriers raising marketing, broadening underwriting appetite and lowering average premiums. "We remained disciplined in Direct and deployed capital only where expected returns met our thresholds," CEO Alex Timm wrote in the letter.
Partnership new writings, which include independent agents, grew 19% and made up 52% of total new writings, up from 44% a year earlier. In August Root renewed its Carvana relationship through August 2028, and said more than 250,000 policies had been written through Carvana from September 2022 through August 2026.
In October it launched a Hyundai pilot in 14 Phoenix-area dealerships, offering six months of free Root coverage to eligible customers who finance or lease a new Hyundai through Hyundai Capital America. Root also expanded into Wyoming, bringing it to 38 states.
Buybacks and a new pricing model
Root repurchased $36.2 million of its shares in the quarter under a $75 million authorization.
The company began deploying its newest proprietary pricing model in the fourth quarter and expects it to deliver its largest improvement in predictive power to date.
Timm's letter states the company's goal plainly: to build the largest and most profitable personal lines insurance carrier in the United States.
Sources
- 8-K Filing — Root, Inc. (ROOT) — SEC EDGAR
- Exhibit q32026shareholderletter.htm — Root, Inc. 8-K exhibit — SEC EDGAR
- Root Insurance news, trends and insights - Insurance Journal — insurancejournal.com
- Root CEO Alex Timm: AI Agents and the Evolving Future of Auto Insurance — Yahoo Finance