Rollins CEO Says Pest Control's Customer Discovery 'Changed Probably Forever' As AI Search Cuts Lead Flow
The company trimmed its 2026 organic growth outlook to 4% to 6% and will hold off on a 2027 view until fourth-quarter results.
Rollins, the Orkin parent that sells pest control and termite protection, now says AI-driven search has permanently altered how customers find providers. CEO Jerry Gahlhoff told analysts on the company's third-quarter earnings call that this world "has changed probably forever in this space" and that Rollins will never be able to say it is "done" and has "arrived."
Outlook cut to 4% to 6% organic growth
Executive Vice President and CFO Will Harkins said on the call that Rollins now expects 2026 organic growth of 4% to 6%, below the 6% outlook it gave after the second quarter. That earlier figure assumed residential lead declines would hold steady; instead, he said, volatility persisted and lead volumes weakened further.
The midpoint of about 5% assumes leads stay below last year's level but stabilize at third-quarter levels. The 4% low end assumes further deterioration, and the 6% high end assumes meaningful improvement. Harkins flagged November and December as seasonally slow months when the short-cycle residential business is more sensitive to demand and weather. Incremental margins are now expected to run from slightly positive to 10% for 2026.
Management will hold off on any 2027 view until it reports fourth-quarter results; Gahlhoff said that call comes in February. Third-quarter organic growth was 4.4%, which Harkins said was below expectations, on total revenue growth of 6.2%. Organic growth was 2.3% in residential, 6.6% in commercial and 5.3% in termite and ancillary. Adjusted earnings were $0.34 a share.
Why leads are drying up
Gahlhoff opened by saying the quarter missed expectations and that the main problem is pressure on residential customer acquisition. He said large language models recommend a wider range of pest control providers than traditional search, and that results differ by platform, by market and even for the same search run on different days.
Asked by a William Blair analyst how leads trended, Gahlhoff said organic website traffic fell 13% year over year in August but only 4% in September, and organic search leads improved 5% since July. He cautioned that Rollins does not know whether the gains will last. Brands built on door-to-door sales and home-builder partnerships, such as HomeTeam and Fox, grew well above the company average.
A Bernstein analyst said Rollins averages about 13 Yelp reviews per store against 25 to 30 for competitors, and that ChatGPT leans on Yelp. Gahlhoff did not dispute the point, but said Yelp works differently from Google reviews, where Rollins is stronger, and would take much more time to move.
The response, and the shares
Gahlhoff said Rollins is adding pricing transparency that LLMs now pick up, localizing content and testing paid ads on ChatGPT and Google Gemini. Harkins said the plan is to reallocate marketing money, not spend more. Asked by a Jefferies analyst why not spend aggressively to take share, Gahlhoff said doing so without knowing the return would be irresponsible.
On costs, gross margin was 53.5%, down 90 basis points (0.9 percentage points) from a year earlier on higher insurance and claims costs and fuel. Adjusted EBITDA was $257 million, down 0.7%. Rollins repurchased $120 million of shares and announced another 10% dividend increase.
Shares fell 7.4% in after-hours trading after the results, then were up 4.33% to $34.90 in Thursday morning trading, market data showed.
Harkins said Rollins still believes it can return to its 7% to 8% organic growth target, though he said management does not know when.
Sources
- Rollins (ROL) Q3 Earnings and Revenues Miss Estimates — Yahoo Finance
- Rollins stock falls as revenue misses estimates, pest control growth slows (ROL:NYSE) | Seeking Alpha — seekingalpha.com
- Rollins: Q3 Earnings Snapshot — Associated Press
- Rollins falls 7% on third quarter earnings and revenue miss — Yahoo Finance
- Rollins Q3 Adj. EPS $0.34, Inline, Sales $1.0... — benzinga.com