Reddit CEO Says Logged-In-Only Is Coming: 'This Is A Test, But We Are Going To Make This Transition'

Steve Huffman said falling search referrals could cut Reddit's 130 million daily users by a low double-digit percentage in the fourth quarter.

Share
Reddit CEO Says Logged-In-Only Is Coming: 'This Is A Test, But We Are Going To Make This Transition'

Reddit will move to a logged-in-only experience, co-founder and CEO Steve Huffman said on the company's third-quarter earnings call Thursday, and he warned that sliding Google referrals could cut its 130 million daily users by a low double-digit percentage in the fourth quarter.

Search referrals fall by a million a week

Reddit runs a social platform of user-created communities called subreddits, and it earns most of its money from advertising. Huffman said search referral traffic fell meaningfully in the third quarter, with the decline accelerating late in the quarter and continuing into the fourth.

In October, search traffic dropped by more than 1 million referrals a week on average, he said. If that pace holds, total daily active uniques could fall by a low double-digit percentage from the current base of 130 million.

His hypothesis, answering a Raymond James analyst, was that Google's AI overviews and AI mode are the biggest factor, with lower ranking of Reddit's machine-translated content a second one outside the US. Reddit is still among the most-searched words on Google, he said, so the shift reflects Google not sending people to the site the way it used to.

A test with a fixed destination

Asked by a Jefferies analyst whether logged-in-only is merely a test, Huffman said: "This is a test, but we are going to make this transition." He cited engagement, ad targeting, protection of Reddit's data corpus and a firmer footing for emerging regulation, and said Reddit is now the only platform that does not require login, a gap that has long let anyone read most of the site without an account.

Testing begins in the fourth quarter in select markets outside the US, and the results will shape a global version. Some form of Reddit will remain open before the hard login prompt, he said, and the tests will settle which pages get the wall.

Huffman was blunt about the cost: "we will likely be trading reach for engagement." He said more than 80% of Reddit's monetization comes from app and logged-in users. He added that logged-in-only will make scraping harder, calling that one of the reasons for the move, and that the vast majority of scraping happens among logged-out users.

What the model can't yet say

An Oppenheimer analyst asked how to model the shift. Huffman said the test exists to answer that: logged-in-only will assuredly grow the logged-in base, but "what the conversion rate is over time, we just don't know."

On whether logged-out traffic falls to zero, he said he could not say, but over the long term he expects app, logged-in and total daily users to "more or less converge."

Only about 13% of eligible mobile web users currently see the prompt to switch to the app, which he described as room to scale.

Revenue up 53%, outlook for the fourth quarter

The business is still growing quickly. Revenue rose 53% from a year earlier to $895 million, and advertising revenue climbed 54% to $847 million, according to the call. Net income was $283 million, and free cash flow was $363 million.

For the fourth quarter, Chief Financial Officer Drew Vollero guided to revenue of $1 billion to $1.03 billion and adjusted EBITDA of $480 million to $510 million. Reddit will keep reporting logged-in and logged-out users by geography, he said.

Reddit's fourth-quarter test in markets outside the US will be the first read on how many visitors convert once the login wall goes up.

Sources

More on Reddit

All Reddit (RDDT) coverage →