PROG CEO Says The 'Six' In Its 6%-To-8% Write-Off Range Is 'Not Really Appropriate Anymore'

Steve Michaels said write-offs of 8.3% of leasing revenue point to a full year near the high end of the target band.

Share
PROG CEO Says The 'Six' In Its 6%-To-8% Write-Off Range Is 'Not Really Appropriate Anymore'

PROG Holdings CEO Steve Michaels said on the company's Wednesday earnings call that the low end of its long-held lease write-off range no longer fits the business, as Progressive Leasing write-offs ran at 8.3% of leasing revenue in the third quarter. "I'm not making news here and changing that range, but I would say the six part of that six to eight is not really appropriate anymore," said Michaels, who is chairman, president and CEO.

Write-offs near the top of the band

PROG Holdings, a financial technology company whose largest segment, Progressive Leasing, leases furniture, appliances and electronics to consumers with weaker credit, put its write-offs at 8.3% of leasing revenue, CFO Brian Garner said. That compares with 8.4% in the second quarter and 7.4% a year earlier.

Garner said the year-over-year gap looks elevated largely because of the significant tightening a year earlier and tougher conditions for customers. He expects full-year 2026 leasing write-offs near the high end of the 6% to 8% annual target.

Michaels went further when a B. Riley analyst asked how confident management was of landing in the range after several rounds of tightening. He said he was not sure "that we or you would want us to run the business down in the sixes," arguing that the gross margin of the business has structurally changed over recent years.

Tightening that cost growth

Michaels said the credit tightening put "several hundred basis points" of pressure on third-quarter leasing gross merchandise volume (the value of goods leased), and that management would expect that "probably in Q4 as well." Approval rates are down nearly 300 basis points from a year ago, both in the quarter and year to date.

Leasing volume still grew 2.3% to $420.4 million, and Michaels said the gross lease asset balance turned positive year over year for the first time since April 2025. Leasing revenue was $552.7 million, down 0.7%. Garner said he expects revenue to grow in the fourth quarter.

Michaels said some pre-tightening lease pools deteriorated after the July call, prompting further action. He said those pools will be largely through the portfolio by year-end, with some remnants into the first quarter. Garner said the 2026 changes have been smaller and more iterative than the single large move in the first quarter of 2025.

Lower outlook, bigger buyback

Management cut its 2026 outlook, citing a consumer squeezed by inflation and higher fuel prices since March. It now expects revenue of $3.015 billion to $3.05 billion, adjusted EBITDA of $345 million to $355 million and adjusted earnings per share of $4.70 to $4.85.

PROG also said it intends to start a $100 million accelerated share repurchase, with an initial delivery of about 2.7 million shares. The board replenished the buyback authorization to $500 million.

Garner expects leasing revenue to grow in the fourth quarter, as the lease asset base rebuilds.

Sources

More on PROG Holdings

All PROG Holdings (PRG) coverage →