Old Republic CEO Sees Auto Warranty Premium Of 'Six, 700 Million' In Coming Years, Maybe More
Craig Smiddy said the fast-growing warranty line is less tied to the underwriting cycle, and flagged a collateral loss on one program.
Old Republic's auto warranty business could reach net annual premium of "six, 700 million in the next few years" and "even higher," CEO Craig Smiddy said on the insurer's third-quarter earnings call Thursday. Specialty net premiums written rose 10.5% in the quarter, but 4.4% once the ECM acquisition and the write-up portion of auto warranty are stripped out.
A warranty book on the rise
Old Republic International, the Chicago-based insurance holding company with specialty and title segments, has written auto warranty for many decades through vehicle service contract programs with dealers and administrators, Smiddy said. It recently decided to expand by partnering with market-leading administrators.
A Raymond James analyst noted that year-to-date net written premium for the combined home and auto warranty line was 545.9, up from 350 a year earlier, and asked whether it was a $750 million to $800 million book. Smiddy said the growth is driven by auto warranty, which is rising significantly on both a gross and a net basis. Pressed on whether the $600 million to $700 million figure was annual, he answered: "Annual premium."
He called the business an attractive source of growth and diversification because its results depend less on the property-casualty underwriting cycle and more on the quality of administrator partnerships.
Cleaner view of the combined ratio
Specialty's combined ratio was 96% against 94.8% a year earlier. Management now also reports a version excluding retail write-up auto warranty, which Smiddy said reached an inflection point where it is material to the reported expense and loss ratios. On that basis the expense ratio was 29.9, against 30.2 a year ago.
A $20 million credit charge added 1.4 percentage points to the quarter's expense ratio. Smiddy said one program performed very poorly and sits in a collateral deficit, and the company booked what it believes is the ultimate loss. He said he does not see it as systemic and expects no further developments.
Smiddy said the company will keep supplying exhibits showing results with and without ECM and auto warranty, and that both should keep lifting growth.
Quarter, cycle and title
Consolidated pre-tax operating income was $227 million, against $248 million a year earlier, with a combined ratio of 96.1 versus 95.3. Net operating income was $181 million, or 73 cents a share, compared with $197 million, or 78 cents. The company repurchased $114 million of shares in the quarter and another $60 million since, leaving about $460 million on its authorization.
Smiddy said the company is at the top of its 90-to-95 combined ratio target and will work not to exceed it in a softer market, with top-line shrinkage the wild card. Newer startup operating companies have collectively grown about 40% year to date, he said.
In title, premiums and fees earned rose 7.3% and pre-tax operating income was $50 million, up from $46 million. Smiddy said higher mortgage rates "give us pause," though commercial strength is offsetting residential softness.
Smiddy said he expects "some good news to report" when the company reports year-end results on next quarter's call.
Sources
- Old Republic International (ORI) Lags Q3 Earnings Estimates — Yahoo Finance
- Old Republic: Q3 Earnings Snapshot – WTOP News — wtop.com
- Old Republic Intl Q3 Adj. EPS $0.73 Misses $0... — benzinga.com
- Exploring Analyst Estimates for Old Republic (ORI) Q3 Earnings, Beyond Revenue and EPS — Yahoo Finance
- Old Republic (ORI) Q3 Earnings: Taking a Look at Key Metrics Versus Estimates — Yahoo Finance