Morgan Stanley's Gorman: 'Perhaps I Was Mistaken' On Private Equity Leading The Deal Cycle

The bank's chief executive said corporate buyers are setting the pace while some buyout firms hold out for valuations the market will not pay.

Share
Morgan Stanley's Gorman: 'Perhaps I Was Mistaken' On Private Equity Leading The Deal Cycle

Morgan Stanley Chairman and Chief Executive Officer James P. Gorman said on the bank's third-quarter earnings call Wednesday that "perhaps I was mistaken" to think a couple of years ago that private equity might lead the corporate finance lifecycle. Asked about the backlog of sponsor mandates, he said it is "the strategic real corporate universe" that is leading, as investment banking revenue came in at $2.2 billion, up 2% from a year earlier, per CFO Sharon Yeshaya.

What Gorman said about sponsors

A TD Cowen analyst asked how the logjam in sponsor mandates breaks, calling it a waiting game for the last couple of years. Gorman gave two answers, starting with the positive: at some point "The Piper Must Be Paid," meaning portfolios need to be harvested.

He noted that continuation funds and other engineering have bought time, and that some smart private equity investors may want to keep assets in a higher-rate world if they can earn low to mid double-digit returns.

His less positive answer: "it is a little frustrating." Some sponsors, he said, are stuck on valuation marks that will not come to pass, because the market is sharp about what is in their portfolios and about the new cost of capital.

He said sponsors "have to hustle to keep up" with the strategic bid and strategic demand for capital. He still called the sponsor backlog a positive tailwind "with some conditionality," and expects the best private equity partners to bring companies to market by IPO or sale against a favorable regulatory backdrop.

The numbers behind the backlog

Yeshaya said advisory revenue was $887 million, equity underwriting was $525 million, down from broad-based strength a year earlier, and fixed income underwriting was $747 million. She said pipelines remain robust and diversified across products, sectors and regions.

Reuters reported that global deal value fell 41% from the previous quarter to $993 billion, according to LSEG data.

Firmwide, the bank reported revenue of $20.3 billion and a return on tangible equity of 22.6%. Gorman said July and August were brisk before higher rates and Middle East tensions slowed markets after Labor Day.

Gorman put the sponsor question in terms of timing: the open point is when and how holdouts come to market, a call he said he would not bet on many of them making smoothly.

Sources

More on Morgan Stanley

All Morgan Stanley (MS) coverage →