Medicare Advantage Plans Would Face Tougher Bonus Tests Under CMS's Proposed 15-Measure Ratings

CMS also proposed nutrition standards for food benefits and a mandatory state-level payment experiment beginning in 2029.

Share
Medicare Advantage Plans Would Face Tougher Bonus Tests Under CMS's Proposed 15-Measure Ratings

Medicare Advantage plans would have to clear a higher bar to earn quality bonuses under changes the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) proposed Friday. The agency's release outlined a 15-measure ratings system alongside new food-benefit standards and easier application requirements for plans seeking to enter the market.

Bonuses Would Depend On Tougher Ratings

CMS would change how it calculates the Star Ratings that assess care and drug services in Medicare Advantage and Part D prescription drug plans. The proposed calculation changes would make both high ratings and the bonus payments tied to them harder to secure.

The agency wants the ratings to put more weight on clinical outcomes and patients' experience. It would keep selected measures of care processes in priority areas where performance is still low, building on recent revisions to the measures used in the ratings.

The payment proposals extend beyond the ratings system. CMS proposed a mandatory experiment in selected states called Aligning Data and Value to Nurture Competition and Efficiency in Medicare Advantage. If finalized, the model would start in 2029 and run for 10 years, testing a progressively closer connection between quality performance and payment.

CMS said the experiment aims to give regional plans a more equal footing against large national insurers. Plans could direct preventive supplemental benefits specifically to enrollees receiving low-income subsidies, including food and produce, transportation for nonmedical needs and caregiver support.

The experiment would also test a new approach to risk adjustment—the method for accounting for patients' health needs in payments—without using that test to set payments. CMS described the approach as combining multiple methods to improve accuracy. It is considering a future separate payment arrangement for dialysis for people with end-stage renal disease within the model.

Food Benefits Get A Nutrition Test

Food and beverage benefits would need to supply whole foods rich in nutrients that follow the 2025–2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans. The proposed standard would cover supplemental benefits, including a food-and-produce benefit that chronically ill enrollees used nearly 40 million times in 2025. That figure counts uses, not individual patients.

Medical recommendations would provide an exception. A health care provider could recommend an otherwise excluded food or nutritional product for a patient's particular needs, including certain high-calorie oral nutritional supplements.

“Medicare food benefits should pay for nutritious food that helps people improve their health and manage chronic disease,” said HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.

The distinction matters for the proposed coverage terms: the nutrition standard would govern the benefits generally, but a provider's recommendation could preserve access to products outside that standard.

Easier Entry, Broader Audit Exposure

Organizations applying to offer Medicare Advantage plans would demonstrate that their provider networks are adequate in their first year of operation, moving the check out of application review. CMS said that shift would lower an entry barrier and reduce application appeals and delays in plan bids.

CMS would also group clinical psychology, clinical social work and outpatient behavioral health into one specialty category when assessing networks. It proposed expanding the existing credit for telehealth in those assessments.

Plans serving people eligible for both Medicare and Medicaid would get more flexibility in arrangements with Medicaid managed care plans. The proposals concern special needs plans that integrate the two programs' benefits.

Those changes accompany a separate proposed expansion of fraud oversight announced on November 16. That proposal would allow CMS to extend findings from sampled Medicare Advantage patients across an entire plan contract, starting with audits for payment year 2018. Public comments on that proposal are due January 19, 2027.

CMS is also seeking input on possible future expansion of primary care networks and use of artificial intelligence. That request seeks ideas for further exploration; the ratings, nutrition and network changes remain proposals.

The proposed rule's comment period will last 60 days following publication in the Federal Register. The state payment experiment would begin in 2029 only if finalized.

Sources