Koch Puts Truly's Liquid 'On The Table': 'Doing Nothing Is Not An Option'

Boston Beer's founder says the hard seltzer brand's recipe, packaging and positioning are all open to change after a World Cup campaign flopped.

Share
Koch Puts Truly's Liquid 'On The Table': 'Doing Nothing Is Not An Option'

Boston Beer founder Jim Koch said on the company's third-quarter earnings call on Thursday that he will not give up on Truly, its hard seltzer, and that even the liquid in the can is open to change. "Doing nothing is not an option," said Koch, the CEO, brewer and founder.

Everything on the table

Boston Beer makes Twisted Tea, Truly, Samuel Adams, Dogfish Head, Angry Orchard and Sun Cruiser. Asked by an analyst from Goldman Sachs whether it would run Truly for cash or try to steady it, Koch said the plan is to "stabilize or even grow the brand." Truly, he said, is "too big to give up on," and the company could not easily replace its volume if it simply liquidated the brand.

That commitment, he said, "puts the liquid on the table," along with positioning, packaging and the rest of the brand's identity. The reassessment began right after the World Cup, and he said it is one of the top priorities of new Chief Marketing Officer Alison Stransky, who joined Boston Beer earlier this month.

Koch called Truly's market share "unnaturally low," saying it is about a fourth or a fifth of White Claw's. The company is also studying turnarounds of other brands. "Is there a next generation of hard seltzer?" he asked, noting the category is 10 years old.

A World Cup campaign that flopped

Truly was the focus of the company's sponsorship of the U.S. team in the World Cup, with special ads around it. Koch said that campaign did not work: depletions, meaning distributor sales to retailers, did not respond. The company cut the spending significantly.

Some of the money went to Twisted Tea, where Koch said people exposed to the ads buy more, and some to Samuel Adams and Angry Orchard. Interim CFO Matt Murphy said third-quarter advertising spending fell $9.1 million, and that fourth-quarter advertising is expected to drop as Truly investment was reduced.

Truly remains the number two brand in hard seltzer, Koch said, though it faces challenging trends. Murphy said third-quarter depletions fell 5%, with declines in Twisted Tea, Truly and Samuel Adams. In the near term the company is focusing 12-packs on its best-selling flavors and expanding packages of Truly Wild Berry.

Next stop: February guidance

Boston Beer narrowed its 2026 outlook, with non-GAAP earnings per share now seen at $9 to $10.50, up from a prior range of $8.50 to $10.50. Third-quarter gross margin was 51.7%, the highest since 2017, and revenue fell 3.2%.

Koch said the company will give 2027 guidance in February, when it wraps up 2026.

Koch said he will return in February with 2027 guidance, when Boston Beer's plans for Truly may become clearer.

Sources

More on Boston Beer

All Boston Beer (SAM) coverage →