KKR's Scott Nuttall Predicts Some Younger Private-Market Firms Will Disappear
KKR says investors are concentrating commitments with experienced managers as fundraising and cash returned to clients climb.
KKR, which invests in private equity, real assets and credit and runs an insurance business, expects some younger private-market managers to disappear, Co-Chief Executive Officer Scott Nuttall said on the company's earnings call Monday. His argument: 65% of firms have never invested through a real economic cycle, and clients are increasingly directing money toward managers with that experience.
The Experience Gap Behind The Prediction
“Some will disappear,” Nuttall said of newer entrants, while predicting that many others would learn from the current environment and improve. He estimated that more than 65% of private-market participants were established after 2009; fewer than 20% were operating during the 2001 recession.
Nuttall put the industry's assets above $15 trillion, compared with about $3 trillion during the financial crisis. He argued that the more important distinction was how many managers had navigated recessions, rather than how much money the industry now controlled.
KKR's own history stretches back to 1976. Nuttall cited the financial crisis, the 2001 recession, the early-1990s real-estate crisis and the early-1980s recession as experiences that changed its investment methods.
“A lot of the mistakes that other people are making now, we made a couple decades ago or more,” he said. The claim was about lessons learned, rather than an assurance of flawless investing: Nuttall also acknowledged that KKR would keep making mistakes.
The argument comes with KKR shares having lost about 24% since the start of the year, as of Monday's original report. Its market value was $86.6 billion as of 11:41 a.m. ET Monday.
Fundraising Tests The Experience Argument
An analyst asked for tangible evidence that investment clients recognized those differences—whether they were attracting new investors, speeding fundraising or encouraging clients to commit across strategies.
Nuttall pointed to meetings with investors in Europe, the Middle East and Asia. He said clients noticed that experienced firms were returning more cash and producing better portfolio results, and that the distinction was helping KKR raise private-equity and infrastructure funds.
His comparison was with 2010–2020, when he said rising markets obscured the benefits of diversification, steady investment pacing and careful portfolio construction. He expects performance differences between managers to become more pronounced and commitments to concentrate further.
The fundraising figures give that account a concrete test. Craig Larson, KKR's Partner and Head of Investor Relations, reported $25 billion of new capital in the third quarter and $116 billion over the trailing 12 months. The latest flagship global infrastructure fund closed at $19.2 billion, compared with $17 billion for its predecessor.
KKR earns management and transaction fees and a share of investment gains. Its Global Atlantic insurance arm sells retirement and life-insurance products and earns a spread on investments. Those businesses sit alongside Strategic Holdings, KKR's direct stakes in companies.
Larson reported third-quarter adjusted net income of $1.78 per share, up 26% from a year earlier, and fee-related earnings of $1.42 per share, up 24%. Management fees reached $1.2 billion—the amount KKR earned across all of 2019.
Higher Rates, Same Operating Playbook
An RBC Capital Markets analyst challenged whether higher interest rates required KKR to change how it improved private-equity businesses. Nuttall described the environment as “a return to normalcy” and said the firm did not need a wholesale overhaul of its operating tools.
He contrasted a roughly 5% Treasury rate with the 5.8% average 10-year Treasury yield since KKR's founding and the 2.7% average since the beginning of 2010. His point was that the low-rate period familiar to public-market investors was not the firm's entire experience.
Nuttall argued that buying at lower valuation multiples and increasing a company's profitability could matter more to investment returns than changes in borrowing costs. That remains management's investment case, not a guarantee that higher rates leave returns untouched.
USI Cash And Shareholder Control
Rob Lewin, KKR's Chief Financial Officer, said the firm had returned $31 billion to clients in private equity, real assets and credit during the year to date. Including announced deals and activity completed since September 30, he expected distributions to exceed $40 billion in 2026—more than 50% above the previous annual record.
The pending USI sale, announced in late August, is expected to generate approximately $3.3 billion of after-tax proceeds and about $2 billion of adjusted net income. Lewin said KKR would weigh buybacks, Strategic Holdings investments, acquisitions and insurance when reinvesting that cash, without assigning a fixed amount to any category.
KKR had already repurchased or retired more than $900 million of stock since the year's start, at an average purchase price of $92.00 per share. Lewin argued that repurchases would increase long-term earnings per share.
Lewin said KKR would finish moving to one-share, one-vote governance by its next earnings call. That transition will end the super-voting rights held by co-founders Henry Kravis and George Roberts.
Sources
- KKR & Co. Inc. (KKR) Q3 Earnings and Revenues Beat Estimates — Yahoo Finance
- KKR Triples ‘Mini Berkshire’ Profit to Top Analyst Estimates (1) — news.bloomberglaw.com
- Compared to Estimates, KKR & Co. (KKR) Q3 Earnings: A Look at Key Metrics — Yahoo Finance
- KKR Q3 earnings beat helped by strong fee-related earnings, solid capital raising (KKR:NYSE) | Seeking Alpha — seekingalpha.com
- KKR Delivers Record Profits for Second Straight Quarter As Assets Top $800 Billion — benzinga.com