Kimco Says Private Buyers Pay 5% To 6% Cap Rates For Grocery Centers, While Its Stock Implies Mid-To-High 7%

CEO Conor Flynn used the gap to defend $150 million of third-quarter buybacks funded by apartment and ground-lease sales.

Share
Kimco Says Private Buyers Pay 5% To 6% Cap Rates For Grocery Centers, While Its Stock Implies Mid-To-High 7%

Kimco Realty, which owns grocery-anchored open-air shopping centers, says its stock is priced as if its properties were worth far less than private buyers pay. CEO Conor Flynn said on the company's third-quarter earnings call Thursday that private pricing for such centers sits at a 5% to 6% cap rate (property income relative to value), while Kimco's share price implies a mid-to-high 7% range.

A valuation gap, backed by buybacks

Flynn said Kimco believes its valuation does not reflect the quality and growth of the business, and called the disconnect a "compelling opportunity." He said the 5% to 6% range is consistent with where Kimco bought and sold this year.

The company put money behind that view. CFO Glenn Cohen said Kimco repurchased $150 million of common shares in the quarter at a weighted average price of $23.80, an FFO (funds from operations, a REIT earnings measure) yield of roughly 8%. It also bought back about $74 million of preferred stock, and Cohen called both accretive uses of capital.

Answering an Evercore ISI analyst, Cohen said the buybacks were additive to guidance. They were funded by low-cap-rate residential sales that could not be 1031-exchanged (a tax-deferral swap into other property), he said, with Kimco earning around 8% while selling at 5.1%.

Asked by a Scotiabank analyst whether buybacks might become a bigger focus, Flynn said leverage gives Kimco capacity to buy shares opportunistically. Selling assets and capturing that spread is "a no-brainer in terms of capital allocation," he said.

Selling flat growth, buying grocery

Flynn described a flywheel: Kimco sells flat-growth ground leases, single-tenant properties and apartments built on its own parking lots, then reinvests in higher-growth grocery centers. Disposals this year averaged roughly a 5% cap rate. President and Chief Investment Officer Ross Cooper said Kimco has sold $391 million of assets year to date at a weighted average cap rate of 5.1% and bought $118 million at 5.8%.

Cooper said the outlook assumes acquisition cap rates of about 6%, against low-5% dispositions. The bigger difference is growth: the centers Kimco is buying should grow about 250 to 300 basis points faster annually. Flynn said roughly 14,000 apartment units are built, active or entitled, a source of additional currency over time.

Kimco raised expected transaction volume to $400 million to $500 million, still net neutral for the year.

Guidance up, deals due soon

Kimco raised full-year FFO guidance to $1.84 to $1.86 per diluted share and same-property NOI growth to 3.5% to 3.8%. Third-quarter FFO was $0.47 per share, up 6.8%, and same-property NOI rose 4.9%.

Cooper said two grocery-anchored acquisitions in a top 50 US metro market should close within days, and the company will give details once they do. Kimco will release its full 2027 outlook with fourth-quarter results.

Kimco will lay out the two Florida-style grocery deals' details after closing and its 2027 outlook with fourth-quarter results.

Sources

More on Kimco Realty

All Kimco Realty (KIM) coverage →