Karooooo CEO Says Reported Margins Mislead, And He Hasn't Looked At Competitors
Founder Zach Calisto told analysts margins need a five-to-six-year average, and declined to commit to more operating leverage.
On Karooooo's second-quarter earnings call on Tuesday, founder and group CEO Zach Calisto told analysts that a dip in operating margin is "not necessarily a true reflection of the underlying business." Asked whether rivals are cutting back investment, he said he has not looked.
Why Calisto says margins mislead
Responding to a question on the call about a slight dip in operating margin, Calisto said customer acquisition costs are expensed up front while the revenue arrives over the next couple of years, so the two are not aligned. Margins, he said, need averaging "over a period of five or six years" to show the real figure.
He added that if the company assumed it was not growing, operating margin "goes all the way up to around 40%." Management, he said, is "more focused on our unit economics than actually the IFRS reporting."
The company's own figures for the quarter: total revenue rose 22% to 1,640 million ZAR, and operating profit rose 19% to a record 422 million ZAR. Sales and marketing expenses rose 16%, against 33% in the first quarter.
Competitors, OEMs and operating leverage
An analyst at Needham asked whether competitors were pulling back investment. Calisto said: "I haven't really looked at the competitive environment and what exactly are they doing. So I cannot answer that."
On factory-installed telematics from vehicle makers, he said such systems typically do not give customers what they need, focusing on safety and vehicle maintenance. Even when Karooooo wins OEM business, he said, it ends up putting in its own hardware.
An analyst at Roth asked whether controlled operating expenses would bring more operating leverage in the second half of fiscal 2027 and in fiscal 2028. Calisto said: "I don't want to commit to this because we've got to be quite agile in our thinking." He said the biggest lever is sales and marketing.
Cash flow and what comes next
Chief Financial Officer Hoe Shin Goy said first-half free cash flow reflects a ZAR966 million investment in in-vehicle IoT devices, including memory, to buffer against rising memory prices. She said that investment rose 86%, and that management expects more robust free cash flow in the second half.
Calisto said that by the fourth quarter the company should have better visibility on how to execute in fiscal 2028. Management reiterated its fiscal 2027 outlook.
Karooooo's fourth-quarter update is where Calisto says fiscal 2028 plans should come into clearer view.
Sources
- Karooooo Limited Shares Fall on 2Q Earnings Miss — MarketWatch
- Karooooo Non-GAAP EPS of ZAR 9.28, revenue of ZAR 1.64B (NASDAQ:KARO) | Seeking Alpha — seekingalpha.com
- Karooooo Q2 Earnings Call Highlights — Yahoo Finance
- Karooooo Ltd (KARO) (Q2 2027) Earnings Call Highlights: Record Subscriber Adds and 22% Revenue ... — Yahoo Finance
- Karooooo Ltd. (KARO) Q2 Earnings Match Estimates — Yahoo Finance