Franklin BSP CEO Says Buybacks Gave Him 'New Religion' On Selling Distressed Assets At A Loss

The mortgage REIT will accept discounted sales of troubled assets if the cash funds share repurchases, with about $300 million of equity tied up.

Share
Franklin BSP CEO Says Buybacks Gave Him 'New Religion' On Selling Distressed Assets At A Loss

Franklin BSP Realty Trust, a real estate finance company that lends against commercial property and originates multifamily loans, will now take losses on troubled assets if the cash buys back its own shares, CEO Richard Byrne told analysts on the company's third-quarter earnings call on Thursday.

Buybacks change the math on losses

Share repurchases are "so accretive" that they change "your religion around defending book value marks," Byrne said. Taking a loss against the company's cost basis, he said, "gets completely offset and then some" by buying back shares where they trade.

That has given management "a little bit of new religion" on sales, Byrne said, which he expects will speed the pace. A little price flexibility, he said, could help "materially" in a market where little is happening.

During the quarter the company repurchased 7.4 million shares, about 7.7% of its beginning-2026 share count, while redeploying roughly $300 million of CLO proceeds into new investments, CFO Jerry Baglien said. A CLO is a pool of loans financed by debt; Baglien said keeping those structures requires reinvesting proceeds rather than letting the debt amortize.

$300 million stuck in problem assets

At quarter end, about $300 million of equity was tied up in non-performing loans, underperforming loans and real estate owned, or REO, meaning properties taken over through foreclosure, Baglien said. He called resolving them the highest priority.

Co-President Brian Buffone said the company ended September with 13 watchlist loans totaling $334 million, about 8% of the loan portfolio, down from 10% last quarter. Seven are rated five, the weakest tier mentioned, and the company is pursuing sales on most of them.

REO stood at 10 assets with $340 million of book value, up about $140 million from last quarter as loans moved over from the watchlist. Two are under signed purchase agreements, and a Houston multifamily asset sold after quarter end.

Asked about REO held for investment, Baglien said the company is evaluating moving on it "100%" and would recycle out of some in an opportune exit, though it ranks behind the foreclosure assets.

Rates, reserves and a $407 million cushion

The company reported a net loss of $27 million, or $0.36 per fully converted share, including a $37.7 million provision for expected loan losses, mostly on legacy multifamily assets. Distributable earnings were $3.3 million, or $0.02 per share, after about $22 million of realized losses. Fully converted book value was $14.26 a share, up two cents.

Buffone blamed the Treasury market for slow sales: at a 4.5% 10-year yield six months ago he would have expected far more volume, but it moved to 5.25% and is settling near 5%.

Liquidity was about $407 million and net leverage 2.7 times. Shares are down about 36% this year, and Byrne said they trade at a significant discount to book value.

Buffone said the company is actively marketing most of its REO and risk-rated five loans, and Byrne said management expects progress in the coming quarters.

Sources

More on Franklin BSP Realty Trust

All Franklin BSP Realty Trust (FBRT) coverage →