Erie Indemnity CEO NeCastro Retires Two Months Early, Brian Bolash Takes Interim Job

The insurer's board is still searching for a permanent CEO after moving the retirement up from December 31 for personal reasons.

Share
Erie Indemnity CEO NeCastro Retires Two Months Early, Brian Bolash Takes Interim Job

Erie Indemnity President and CEO Timothy G. NeCastro retired on Monday, weeks ahead of the December 31 exit the company had announced earlier, and Executive Vice President Brian W. Bolash is now interim chief executive, according to an 8-K filed Tuesday.

An earlier exit, for personal reasons

The company said NeCastro's retirement date was accelerated for personal reasons. It had previously said he would step down on December 31, 2026.

Bolash, 61, became Interim President and CEO effective Tuesday. He has been Executive Vice President since January 2022, and before that served as Secretary and General Counsel since October 2019.

The filing says there were no immediate changes in compensation tied to the moves, and no family relationship or special arrangement connected to Bolash's appointment.

What Erie Indemnity does

Erie Indemnity manages the business affairs of the Erie Insurance Exchange, a reciprocal insurer that writes property and casualty coverage, acting as attorney-in-fact for the Exchange's policyholders. The Exchange is its sole customer, and its main revenue is a management fee of up to 25% of the premiums the Exchange writes.

Personal lines, mainly auto and homeowners, made up 71% of the Exchange's 2025 written premiums, and commercial lines the remaining 29%, all sold through independent agencies. As of December 31, 2025, the company had 6,667 full-time employees, according to its annual report.

The search for a permanent CEO

The board's Nominating and Governance Committee continues to work to identify the company's next President and CEO. Bolash holds the top job on an interim basis until that choice is made.

The committee's pick for a permanent President and CEO is the next decision that matters, with Bolash in the seat until then.

Sources

More on Erie Indemnity

All Erie Indemnity (ERIE) coverage →