Crown CEO Says 'We Clearly Got That Wrong' On Middle East Costs, Now 20 To 25 Cents A Share
Tim Donahue also took blame for the transit packaging unit's capital limits as Crown narrowed its full-year profit range to $8.35 to $8.45.
Crown Holdings CEO Tim Donahue said on the company's third-quarter earnings call that management's earlier estimate of Middle East inflation was far too low. "We clearly got that wrong," the chairman, president and chief executive said, as a 5-cent second-quarter and 10-cent back-half hit "morphed into 20 to 25 cents" split between the third and fourth quarters.
What Donahue and the CFO said on the call
Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Kevin Clothier said the conflict cut third-quarter segment income by about $17 million across all businesses, or 12 cents of adjusted earnings per share. He said a similar impact is in the fourth-quarter estimate.
Donahue said the extra cost came partly from volume declines in the Middle East and largely from elevated energy and freight costs globally. Gulf-state volumes fell 4% in the quarter, and he said the fourth-quarter estimate assumes further declines until restrictions at the Strait of Hormuz ease.
Clothier said full-year guidance is centered where it was after the second quarter. The range is now $8.35 to $8.45 in adjusted earnings per share, with volume offsetting the higher inflation. Fourth-quarter adjusted earnings are guided to $1.63 to $1.73.
Third-quarter adjusted earnings were $2.39 a share, up 7% from $2.24. Net sales rose to $3.7 billion from $3.2 billion, and global beverage can volumes grew more than 6%. Segment income was $484 million, against $490 million a year earlier.
Transit packaging and the CEO's own blame
Donahue called transit packaging disappointing, with volumes and profits both short of expectations and freight costs adding to soft demand. He said the fourth quarter should compare with last year much as the third did: down a little.
An analyst from Bank of America asked what would improve the unit. "If you want to blame somebody, blame the CEO of the company. That's me," Donahue said, citing capital he declined to give the team. Crown decided several years ago to run the business for cash, he said.
He said it probably needs a little more capital each year, but "nothing on the order of more than $20 million a year."
The 2027 recovery, and what to watch
Donahue said contractual recovery of these costs comes in 2027 through a look-back formula tied to producer prices, mostly resetting April 1. He said producer prices are running at about 9%.
Asked by a JPMorgan analyst about a benefit of roughly 20 cents a share, Donahue said it would not cover the full amount because Asia and the Middle East lack the mechanism. "Perhaps half of that number" is a fair expectation, he said.
On capital returns, Donahue said Crown has bought back $600 million of stock so far this year and might spend a little over $100 million more. He floated $600 million to $800 million a year in buybacks for several years. Adjusted free cash flow guidance is at least $950 million, up from at least $900 million, which Clothier attributed to better working capital.
Donahue said he would firm up the 2027 price-cost picture when Crown reports in late January.
Donahue said he would give a firmer view of how much of the look-back recovery materializes when Crown next reports, in late January.