Credit Acceptance Cuts Cash-Flow Forecast $291 Million, Says Most Of It Hits Loans Made Before New Scorecard
CEO Vinayak Hegde says none of the markdown relates to litigation, as loan volume grew 38% in the third quarter.
Credit Acceptance, which finances auto dealers' sales to buyers with impaired or limited credit, cut its forecast of future loan collections by $291 million in the third quarter, and CEO Vinayak Hegde said on the company's earnings call Thursday that most of it hits loans written before a new scorecard. Asked by an analyst from TD Cowen whether any of it related to litigation, Hegde said none of it did.
Growing faster, forecasting lower
Hegde said he wanted to "address an important question directly": how the company can grow faster while lowering its forecast for certain existing loan cohorts. His answer was that the majority of the adjustment concerns loans assigned before the new scorecard, its tool for assessing loan risk.
Chief Financial Officer Joe Billante said forecasted net cash flows fell 2.5%, or $291 million, in the quarter, against a decline of 0.5%, or $59 million, a year earlier. He put the revised collection rate for 2025 and 2026 loan vintages at approximately 65%, a modest change, he said, against nearly $12 billion of forecasted net cash flows in the portfolio.
Hegde said the underperformance of loans assigned from 2022 through 2026 was most pronounced in lower score bands. Without the adjustment, he said, "it is possible that quarterly adjustment would have continued through the remaining life of these loans."
Newer loans look better, so far
Third-quarter loans alone were adjusted by 90 basis points, Hegde said, versus 250 basis points for loans assigned from January through June 2026. Early indications on loans under the new scorecard are "encouraging," he said, but they "remain relatively unseasoned" and need more performance history before firm conclusions.
An analyst from Autonomous Research noted that revisions had seemed to be improving until now. Billante said first-quarter results were stronger, and that results began to change late in the second quarter and into the third. Prepayments, he said, were a minor contributor.
On a standard accounting basis the company lost $56.6 million, or $5.43 per diluted share, against net income of $108.2 million a year earlier. Adjusted net income was $135.5 million, or $13.01 per diluted share.
Volume up 38%, share buybacks continue
Loan assignment unit volume rose 38% to more than 110,000 loans, and loan dollar volume rose 51% to $1.4 billion. Active dealers reached a record 12,093. Economic profit, the company's primary metric, rose 18% to $50.7 million, or $4.87 per diluted share, up 30%.
The company repurchased 269,150 shares for $161.6 million and ended September with $1.2 billion of liquidity. Operating expenses fell 10%, and the company cut its team by about 6%.
Hegde said the scorecard is "an important step, not the end state," and that performance on newer loans will need more seasoning to judge.
Sources
- Credit Acceptance signals ~65% forecasted collection rate for 2025-2026 vintages while expanding dealer network (NASDAQ:CACC) | Seeking Alpha — seekingalpha.com
- Credit Acceptance: Q3 Earnings Snapshot — Associated Press
- Credit Acceptance Non-GAAP EPS of $13.01 beats by $0.67, revenue of $594.6M misses by $1.8M (NASDAQ:CACC) — seekingalpha.com
- Credit Acceptance Announces Third Quarter 2026 Results — globenewswire.com