CMS Wants Power To Suspend Marketplace Brokers Over Allegations Of Harmful Conduct
The proposal pairs consumer protections with Medicare payment audits and broader Medicaid provider checks.
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) proposed Monday that it be allowed to immediately suspend brokers from the health insurance Marketplace over credible allegations of abusive conduct that could harm consumers or the Exchange. The broker restrictions are part of a wider proposed rule that CMS estimates could save taxpayers nearly $90 billion over 10 years.
Faster Suspensions, A Separate Termination Test
Consumers enrolled in a health plan without consent, or switched into coverage they did not choose, are a central target of the proposal. CMS would gain stronger powers over agents, brokers and web-brokers who use the Marketplace to arrange coverage.
An immediate suspension would require a credible allegation of abusive conduct causing harm, or likely to cause harm, to a consumer or the Exchange. Terminating a broker's Exchange agreement would require a different finding: a preponderance of the evidence, meaning the evidence weighs more heavily in favor of the conduct having occurred.
CMS also proposes restricting access for those with certain felony convictions and those currently excluded or debarred from federally funded healthcare programs. Brokers could face termination and other penalties if they fail to refute identified noncompliance within 30 calendar days.
The proposal would require reasonable safeguards against access to Marketplace systems from outside the United States. That requirement includes attempts made through virtual private networks that route traffic outside the country.
CMS Deputy Administrator and Chief Operating Officer Kim Brandt described the consumer stakes in the agency's release: “Behind every fraudulent claim is a real person: a senior whose identity was stolen, a family switched into a plan they never chose, a patient denied the care they were promised.”
Medicare Audits Would Test Diagnosis Claims
The broader package, named Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare, would tighten scrutiny of payments across Medicare, Medicaid and the Children's Health Insurance Program, alongside the Marketplace restrictions.
For Medicare Advantage, CMS proposes stronger audits of the diagnosis information plans submit to obtain payments adjusted for patients' health risks. The audits would seek to recover improper payments when medical records do not support diagnoses that inflated a beneficiary's risk score.
Medicare Advantage organizations and Part D prescription-drug plan sponsors would have to report suspicious or substantiated fraud, waste and abuse. Certain providers and suppliers serving Medicare Advantage plans would also have to enroll in Original Medicare so CMS could check their credentials and screen them for risks.
CMS could deny or revoke enrollment when it cannot confirm a provider's or supplier's owners' identities or locations, or when they pose an undue risk of fraud, waste or abuse. Providers would have to report every change to enrollment information within 30 calendar days.
Other provisions address medical supply companies' contact with seniors: unsolicited texts, social media messages, emails without an opt-out and door-to-door visits. The package also calls for prompt reporting and repayment of identified fee-for-service overpayments.
CMS Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz said the proposal would give the agency stronger authority against schemes involving nonexistent medical supplies, fraudulent hospice enrollment of healthy seniors and Marketplace sign-ups without consent.
Medicaid Screening Would Reach Individual Providers
States would be allowed to rely on a CMS or other federal agency determination to establish a credible allegation of fraud. The proposal would expand the information states report about fraud and abuse, including providers' addresses and National Provider Identifiers, the identification numbers used for healthcare providers.
States would have to collect and use those identifiers for every eligible individual Medicaid and Children's Health Insurance Program provider. New enrollment-denial and termination grounds would align with Medicare's, with broader disclosures about owners and managers and more extensive monthly state reporting of denials and terminations.
The package would also tighten beneficiary eligibility oversight, overpayment recovery and corrective-action requirements for states with identified weaknesses. CMS proposes closer scrutiny of deductions from Medicaid payments and more reporting about potential fraud and improper payments in managed care.
Projected Savings Meet Subsidy Negotiations
CMS reported Medicare program-integrity savings of $41.9 billion in fiscal 2025, up 59% from $26.3 billion in fiscal 2024. The agency called the savings a record. It also reported a return of $22.30 for each dollar invested, up 53% from $14.60, which it described as its highest return ever.
The nearly $90 billion estimate concerns potential savings from the proposal over 10 years. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. said the proposed tools would help block fraudulent payments and preserve resources for patient care.
Marketplace subsidies were already being negotiated as part of healthcare spending discussions. President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance had indicated openness to extending the subsidies alongside stronger verification requirements intended to address alleged fraud.
The broker restrictions and payment safeguards remain proposals. Public comments are due January 19, 2027.
Sources
- CMS CRUSH Proposed Rule Aims to Reap Nearly $90 Billion for Taxpayers in Savings by Targeting Fraud Across Medicare, Medicaid/CHIP, and the Marketplace — Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
- Yale researchers map $450 billion in healthcare savings — 3 small fixes alone could save $10 billion a year — Yahoo Finance
- New NICB Intelligence Details Top Emerging Fraud Trends in 2026 and Beyond — Yahoo Finance
- CMS Announces Optional 6-Month Delay for Enforcing Medicaid Work Requirements | KFF Quick Takes — kff.org
- Democrats push Medicaid, ACA tax credits and SNAP in their agenda | Fox News — Fox News
- Nebraska rushed Medicaid work rules. Then a cancer patient was told he’d lost coverage | Fortune — fortune.com