BJ's Defends Over $150 Million In Spending After Underinvesting Its COVID Windfall
Birthday discounts cut merchandise margins, but management is betting that extra trips and new members will deliver lasting returns.
BJ's Wholesale Club, which operates membership warehouse clubs selling groceries, general merchandise and gasoline, invested over $150 million during the quarter, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Bob Eddy said on Friday's earnings call. The spending followed an approximately $240 million settlement benefit, net of legal fees, detailed in the company's results release.
A Windfall Put Into Discounts
Eddy defended the spending by pointing to an opportunity he believes BJ's missed during COVID: “my opinion was we didn't invest enough of that unanticipated upside.” This time, he said, the company wanted to use unexpected money to accelerate its strategy and build lasting member loyalty.
BJ's announced the settlement of its credit-card interchange litigation in early September. Its 42nd birthday campaign offered 42% discounts on selected products, ranging from grocery staples to outerwear, Wagyu steaks and KitchenAid mixers.
Chief Financial Officer Laura Felice put the quarter's one-time promotional spending at an estimated $56 million. Another estimated $95 million went toward compensation, advertising and labor. The company also supported community organizations and gave tenure-based recognition awards to more than 30,000 hourly employees.
Merchandise gross margin fell approximately 1.7 percentage points from a year earlier, a decline BJ's attributed primarily to birthday promotions. Gross profit nevertheless increased 1% to $1.02 billion.
Responding to a Baird analyst's margin question, Eddy said “focusing on the rate loses the plot a little bit.” He argued that gross profit dollars and member engagement mattered more than any particular margin percentage.
More Trips, More Memberships
Traffic at comparable clubs rose 6% year over year during the nearly six-week promotion, while units sold increased 9%. Eddy said the largest increase in shopping frequency came from newer and less-engaged members.
October brought more than 200,000 new member sign-ups, nearly 40% above the average month earlier this year. More than 100,000 members purchased coffee at BJ's for the first time, and targeted own-brand offers were redeemed about 670,000 times.
The membership model makes those additional visits central to management's argument. BJ's serves more than 8.5 million members across 271 clubs in 22 states, collecting annual fees while selling merchandise and fuel. Members can shop through its website, app and delivery services as well as in clubs.
Eddy said established members visiting once a month renew at a rate above 95%, and that renewals improved during and following the promotion. He expects membership fee income growth of about 7.5% as the company exits the year, versus the roughly 6% previously planned.
Third-quarter membership fee income rose 9.5% to $138.4 million. Comparable sales excluding gasoline increased 4.1%.
Earlier Purchases, A Tougher Comparison
Eddy acknowledged that some merchandise sales arrived sooner than they otherwise would have. On general merchandise, he told the Baird analyst, “we absolutely pulled things forward,” explaining that BJ's wanted to secure purchases before competitors did.
KitchenAid mixers had struggled to sell in previous years, he said, but the discounts persuaded members to buy. He expects some limited purchase acceleration in groceries too, while arguing that increased engagement will outweigh that effect.
The experiments are informing holiday promotions. Eddy said ordinary quarterly spending must fit the company's earnings commitments to Wall Street; the settlement allowed broader tests. He said future promotions could change in type without necessarily receiving a larger or smaller budget.
BJ's raised its full-year outlook to adjusted earnings of $5.10 to $5.30 per share and comparable sales growth excluding gasoline of 2.5% to 3.0%. Felice said the earnings range includes the settlement's net benefit after quarterly investments.
Eddy cautioned that another settlement of this kind was unlikely, making this quarter's profitability difficult to repeat. He also said BJ's would not repeat all the associated spending.
Eddy expects BJ's to reach 9 million members during the fourth quarter—the next milestone for the membership expansion behind its spending strategy.
Sources
- BJ's Wholesale Club results release (Form 8-K, EX-99.1) — SEC EDGAR
- Document — sec.gov
- BJ's Wholesale Club is raising full-year earnings forecast after Q3 — qz.com
- BJ’s Wholesale Earnings Beat Has a $240 Million Wrinkle—and the Stock Is Falling — Yahoo Finance
- BJ’s Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. Announces Third Quarter Fiscal 2026 Results — Yahoo Finance
- BJ's Wholesale Club (BJ) Stock Looks Fully Priced On Current Earnings — Yahoo Finance