Berkley CEO Says Commercial Property Will 'Get Uglier Before It Gets Prettier' As Company Pulls Back From Reinsurance

Berkley's chief executive sees liability lines as the opening, with reinsurance premiums down 11.6% to $369 million in the third quarter.

Share
Berkley CEO Says Commercial Property Will 'Get Uglier Before It Gets Prettier' As Company Pulls Back From Reinsurance

Berkley Chairman and Chief Executive Rob Berkley said on the company's third-quarter earnings call that commercial property "is going to get uglier before it gets prettier." Chief Financial Officer Rich Baio told the same call that net premiums written in the reinsurance and monoline excess segment fell 11.6% to $369 million, with casualty the main driver and property a lesser one.

What the call showed

Baio said the quarter produced a record third-quarter underwriting profit of $296 million and operating earnings of $456 million, or $1.17 per share. Annualized operating return on equity was 18.8% for the quarter and over 20% year to date.

The accident-year combined ratio excluding catastrophe losses was 88.1%, with a loss ratio of 59.5%, improved 40 basis points (0.40 percentage points), and an expense ratio of 28.6%. Catastrophe losses were $86 million, up $7 million.

In the insurance segment, gross premiums written grew 4.9% to a third-quarter record of $3.6 billion, and net premiums written grew 3.2% to a record $2.9 billion. Berkley said the renewal retention ratio sits at 80% and "just doesn't move," which he said shows the book is not churning.

Baio said the company has held to underwriting discipline as the reinsurance market stays competitive. The segment still posted $58 million of pre-tax underwriting income.

Where Berkley is steering growth

Berkley said he is dissatisfied with conditions in casualty reinsurance and property, and that the company is "waiting with bated breath, not in a happy way" to see what happens at the January renewals. He said that will in all likelihood be a challenging time. He added that he has heard commentary expecting property reinsurance rates to be off between 10% and 20%, and that Berkley buys more reinsurance than it sells, which he called a good hedge.

Asked by a Wells Fargo analyst whether the view on price and growth had changed, he said much of the liability-related lines "are going to prove to be the opportunity for the foreseeable." Asked by a TD Cowen analyst what he dislikes about casualty reinsurance, he said other firms are willing to rent their capital for a lower price than Berkley is, and that insurance offers a chance to be "less of a commodity."

Other liability premiums rose just shy of 4%, which Berkley said reflects a deliberate shift to smaller accounts rather than rate alone. Asked by a Truist analyst about it, he said larger accounts turn "more zeros into eye candy" that compromises discipline, and that faster quote turnaround is a big edge in small accounts.

He said technology has made the intake of submissions more efficient by 20% plus, which means more quotes on more small accounts.

Technology, capital and the bond portfolio

Berkley opened by saying risk itself is shifting. He pointed to autonomous vehicles possibly moving auto exposure into products liability, and to AI-driven robotics possibly affecting workers' compensation. Asked about timing, he said "I don't know."

On capital, a Wolfe Research analyst noted light buybacks. Berkley said the company still has a 10-figure amount of excess capital and that it buys stock when it sees opportunity, adding that it would be a mistake to read too deeply into the quarter.

Baio said stockholders' equity was more than $9.6 billion at September 30, 2026, after $729 million of capital returned year to date and an $800 million rise in unrealized investment losses due to rising interest rates. Berkley said the domestic fixed-income portfolio sits just inside $24 billion with a book yield of about 4.7%, and that new money earns 80 to 100 basis points more.

Berkley closed the call by saying management looks forward to catching up with analysts "sometime in January," the month of the renewals he flagged.

More on W.R. Berkley

All W.R. Berkley (WRB) coverage →