Axis Capital CEO Says 'We're Not Dour' But Won't Promise 2027 Growth As Property Rates Fall 10%
Pressed on a softening market, Tizzio gave no 2027 guidance after insurance premiums grew 13% in the third quarter.
Axis Capital CEO Vincent Tizzio rejected the idea that he has turned gloomy on property and casualty insurance, then declined to give any 2027 growth outlook, he told analysts on the third-quarter earnings call Thursday. Axis, a specialty insurer and reinsurer, had just reported insurance premiums up 13%.
"We're not dour"
An analyst from TD Cowen said Tizzio sounded more cautious on casualty and property than before, and asked whether double-digit growth could continue next year. "We're not dour. We're not pessimistic," Tizzio replied, adding: "we have humility. The market is softening."
He said Axis took early notice of the softening in the second quarter, and that competitors have since voiced similar views. On 2027, he said the company is not prepared to give commentary or guidance, because "our heads are down" on closing 2026.
Asked whether returns on capital could stay near current levels, he answered "Plus or minus," and told the analyst the company's strong risk-adjusted returns were something he "can take to the bank."
Property rates down 10%
In his prepared remarks, Tizzio said property rates fell 10% in the quarter, including a 15% drop in the excess-and-surplus market, while property growth slowed to 11%. Axis is being more selective where pricing is no longer rational, he said.
Liability rates rose 8%, broadly keeping pace with loss trends, and the company cut exposure where pricing fell short. Cyber rates fell 4%.
Group gross premiums written were $2.4 billion, up 11%, and the combined ratio was 94.0% against 89.4% a year earlier, CFO Matt Kirk said. Net income to common shareholders was $202 million, or $2.75 per diluted share.
War premium and acquisition costs
Kirk said Axis earned about $100 million of premium from marine war business in the quarter, worth around half a point to the attritional loss ratio. That business carries higher commissions; Tizzio put the acquisition cost at 30% to 40% depending on whether Axis leads or follows. Kirk said 22 is a good proxy for the fourth-quarter insurance acquisition ratio.
Axis bought back $109 million of stock in the quarter, up from $89 million in the second quarter, and Kirk said the company expects to keep buying.
Tizzio said Axis will create new products as markets dislocate and will have more to say on them in subsequent calls.
Sources
- Axis Capital Holdings Q3 2026 Earnings Call Transcript — benzinga.com
- Axis Capital (AXS) Tops Q3 Earnings and Revenue Estimates — Yahoo Finance
- Axis Capital: Q3 Earnings Snapshot — Associated Press
- Axis Capital to Release Third Quarter Financial Results on October 28, 2026 – Company Announcement - FT.com — Financial Times
- AXIS Capital Reports Third Quarter Net Income Available to — globenewswire.com