Ameriprise CEO On Advisor Retention Deals: 'There's No Program'

Chairman and CEO Jim Cracchiolo denied a broad retention push, while the CFO said he "scratch[es]" his head at rivals' seven- and eight-year payback offers.

Share
Ameriprise CEO On Advisor Retention Deals: 'There's No Program'

Ameriprise Financial, the wealth and asset manager, has no broad advisor retention-package program, Chairman and CEO Jim Cracchiolo said on the company's Thursday third-quarter earnings call, after analysts from Jefferies, BMO Capital Markets and Evercore ISI asked about press reports that said otherwise. "I would just say there's no program," he said.

Denials, then a distinction

Asked by a Jefferies analyst how widespread package changes were, CFO Walter Berman answered: "First premise, we are not making changes." He said the firm's focus has always been organic growth.

Pressed again by an Evercore ISI analyst on the "elephant in the room," Cracchiolo pointed to "a write-in from an anonymous source" and said "people are trying to make hay out there in different ways." Earlier in the call he described "a lot of noise out there from anonymous sources, from recruiters with their own agendas."

Cracchiolo did say the firm evaluates arrangements with advisors, including practice acquisitions, succession strategies and liquidity, and adjusts for complex teams so deals are equitable. He called that partnership, not a program. Berman said it is done individually, not as a "commodity approach" or "just throwing money."

Rivals' seven- and eight-year paybacks

Berman said that when he reviews competitors' offers, which he described as carrying seven- and eight-year cash paybacks, "I scratched my head." He added that possible interest-rate increases will probably fuel such offers, though he called that outside the firm's control.

Cracchiolo argued that markets and environments change and that private equity may move on if it cannot get its return.

Retention and recruiting numbers

Management said advisor retention is in the high 90% range, including advisors with the firm more than 10 years. Berman said Ameriprise onboarded 79 advisors in the quarter and has "selectively adjusted our offers to reflect the continued competitive environment," while weighing trade-offs between profitability, flows and risk.

Revenue per advisor grew 13% to $1.2 million, and Berman said the organic flow rate stayed in the 4% range. Ameriprise, which has more than 10,000 advisors serving more than 3.5 million retail clients according to its annual report, also finished transitioning Huntington Bank's advisors on October 19.

On capital, the company accelerated its return to $1 billion in the quarter, or 93% of operating earnings, and announced a new $5.5 billion repurchase authorization through September 30, 2028.

Cracchiolo's own summary of the industry's recruiting frenzy: "all is not what it seems."

Sources

More on Ameriprise Financial

All Ameriprise Financial (AMP) coverage →